Dear Prudence, My father is 77 years old. After over 50 years of enthusiastic smoking, he has finally been diagnosed with Stage IV lung cancer. I’m 37 years old and since I can remember I have worried that this day would come. He loves to talk about himself, so he calls me and goes on and on with the latest updates, and how he is sure the next round of treatments will cure him. (The five-year survival rate for people with his diagnosis is 1 percent.) Beginning when I was a small child, I tried to get him to quit by using persuasion, anger, heartfelt letters, throwing out his cigarettes, even family therapy a few years ago, all to no avail. He would often get angry and defensive and even called me "selfish" for describing how his smoking affected me. I'm fed up and having a hard time mustering sympathy for his self-inflicted disease. And he is still smoking! Part of me feels that I should be a loving and supportive daughter to my ill father. But my feelings are so clouded by anger that he has chosen cigarettes over his health and more years with his family that I don't feel like responding with concern and good wishes. Is there anything to do but swallow my feelings and feign polite concern?
—Slow Suicide Is Still Suicide
Dear Slow, According to figures from the CDC, today the American male’s life expectancy at birth is just over 76 years. So while I understand you feel your father’s inability to face down his addiction robbed you of more time with him, you should recognize he has lived a full lifespan. Since you are approaching middle age yourself, if you take a mental survey of your friends, I’m sure you’ll note there are already some who didn’t get as many years with their fathers as you have had with yours. As time goes on, you will see many more of your friends caring for parents whose final years are an agonizing slide into dementia. I despise smoking, and thank goodness the rates continue to go down, to less than 20 percent of adults today. But your father came of age in an era when almost half of adults smoked, and that infernal habit has racked up a huge death toll. The statistics make clear that your father will be added to this list soon. But it’s up to you to decide how to spend what time you have left with him. Imagine it’s five years from now and your father is gone. I doubt you will look back on those last days and be glad you spent them seething with resentment that he couldn’t quit smoking. Angry as you are, try to find a way to open your heart and have some sweet, loving times with your dad, even if they take place outside the hospital while he has a cigarette. There’s no point in his trying to quit now. You know he’ll extinguish his last one soon enough.
—Prudie
__________________
The Principle of Least Interest: He who cares least about a relationship, controls it.
Jaysus. He's 77--not 47. He's going to die from something here before too long, anyway. What real difference does it make that it is this? A few years? Maybe, but we don't really know that, either.
I think this LW needs to cut the proverbial cord.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
He died at 79, and, he quit because he wanted to be around for us.
We thought that lung cancer wouldn't be an issue, since he had almost 25 years, smoke free, before he died. Sadly, no.
I am grateful, that he quit when he did.
I'm sure that added years to his life.
I'm 54, and still smoke.
Not a lot, but, I probably smoke 8 or 10 a day.
It's a hard habit to break.
I'll keep trying.
Hold a good thought, please.
I'm vaping now. I LOVE IT!!!!!
I was vaping for a while, oh4. I did great, for a couple of months.
I kind of fell off the bandwagon.
I think, I just need to quit.
It must be in my DNA, or something.
I just need, to quit.
I tried to smoke a regular cigarette earlier this week. It tasted horrible! LOL! I'm liking the flavored stuff. Not the fruit, but the dark stuff, spices, coffees, ones like that...
__________________
America guarantees equal opportunity, not equal outcome...
It's hard FWM. Mr.VoR quit almost a year ago. I quit in May. I struggle. He used chantax, I just stopped. I've wanted one for several days now and I'm still not sure I won't go buy a pack.
__________________
I'm the Ginger Rogers of spelling...that means I'm smat.
Lesson learned in February: I don't have to keep up, I just have to keep moving!
I smoked for years. Well, except for the time I was pregnant, since I was 18.
A pack a day.
I quit every time I put one out. And every time I lit another I swore it was my last.
Nothing anyone said would have made a difference.
I quit with God's help. When I got serious, I quit.
I could pick it up right now and smoke a pack. I have to make the choice to not smoke every day.
When you are really ready to quit. You will.
__________________
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.
He died at 79, and, he quit because he wanted to be around for us.
We thought that lung cancer wouldn't be an issue, since he had almost 25 years, smoke free, before he died. Sadly, no.
I am grateful, that he quit when he did.
I'm sure that added years to his life.
I'm 54, and still smoke.
Not a lot, but, I probably smoke 8 or 10 a day.
It's a hard habit to break.
I'll keep trying.
Hold a good thought, please.
If your dad could do it...you can do it!! I will send happy healing smoke free thoughts to you. Because I am a little concerned you think 8-10 a day is not a lot. You can do it!!! The power of the geeks is behind you!!
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
My father smoked two packs a day, starting when he was a teenager. He "quit" when he went into a nursing home and couldn't get them any more.
He died of "post-polio" syndrome at age 87.
My mother died at 67. She had a two millimeter lung tumor that spread to her brain. That led to brain surgery and death.
Some people will NOT get lung cancer or have heart attacks due to the effects of smoking. Most smokers WILL and DO get terminal illnesses from smoking.
__________________
The Principle of Least Interest: He who cares least about a relationship, controls it.
I vividly remember an interview I did with a smoker for a research paper many years ago. She was in need of surgery (I forget for what but it was something important) and she had to quit smoking for the surgery. She chose to forgo the surgery. I still don't understand why.
I vividly remember an interview I did with a smoker for a research paper many years ago. She was in need of surgery (I forget for what but it was something important) and she had to quit smoking for the surgery. She chose to forgo the surgery. I still don't understand why.
I know many people like this. Mental health in patients will often leave against medical advice simply for a cigarette. Or won't be admitted at all because of cigarettes. Blush, this was me more than once.
__________________
I'm the Ginger Rogers of spelling...that means I'm smat.
Lesson learned in February: I don't have to keep up, I just have to keep moving!
My father smoked two packs a day, starting when he was a teenager. He "quit" when he went into a nursing home and couldn't get them any more.
He died of "post-polio" syndrome at age 87.
My mother died at 67. She had a two millimeter lung tumor that spread to her brain. That led to brain surgery and death.
Some people will NOT get lung cancer or have heart attacks due to the effects of smoking. Most smokers WILL and DO get terminal illnesses from smoking.
So, in other words it's a crapshoot and all comes down to genetics, anyway.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
My father smoked two packs a day, starting when he was a teenager. He "quit" when he went into a nursing home and couldn't get them any more.
He died of "post-polio" syndrome at age 87.
My mother died at 67. She had a two millimeter lung tumor that spread to her brain. That led to brain surgery and death.
Some people will NOT get lung cancer or have heart attacks due to the effects of smoking. Most smokers WILL and DO get terminal illnesses from smoking.
So, in other words it's a crapshoot and all comes down to genetics, anyway.
No. You are at much higher risk for CERTAIN cancers if you smoke. But, it's not just cancer, it's emphysema, COPD, etc. that can shorten your life, and not make the end years too fun. Not to mention the increased risk of heart disease.
__________________
LawyerLady
I can explain it to you, but I can't understand it for you.
Belive me, smokers know the risks. But at 77, let the man do what he wants. He is already dying. Not having that smoke will cause more stress on his body at this point than having a few puffs.
It's been three years since my last smoke. I still crave it. It smells good to me when someone is actively smoking. The second it gets put out, nasty. But I still crave it. And I am stronger than the craving.
My father smoked two packs a day, starting when he was a teenager. He "quit" when he went into a nursing home and couldn't get them any more.
He died of "post-polio" syndrome at age 87.
My mother died at 67. She had a two millimeter lung tumor that spread to her brain. That led to brain surgery and death.
Some people will NOT get lung cancer or have heart attacks due to the effects of smoking. Most smokers WILL and DO get terminal illnesses from smoking.
So, in other words it's a crapshoot and all comes down to genetics, anyway.
No. You are at much higher risk for CERTAIN cancers if you smoke. But, it's not just cancer, it's emphysema, COPD, etc. that can shorten your life, and not make the end years too fun. Not to mention the increased risk of heart disease.
So? This guy is 77. He already has cancer. He's lived a pretty full life. What difference does it make now?
Heck, what difference would it have made if my father had smoked? He died at 64 and it wasn't lung cancer. It's not likely a few cigs would have made his life much shorter.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
My father smoked two packs a day, starting when he was a teenager. He "quit" when he went into a nursing home and couldn't get them any more.
He died of "post-polio" syndrome at age 87.
My mother died at 67. She had a two millimeter lung tumor that spread to her brain. That led to brain surgery and death.
Some people will NOT get lung cancer or have heart attacks due to the effects of smoking. Most smokers WILL and DO get terminal illnesses from smoking.
So, in other words it's a crapshoot and all comes down to genetics, anyway.
No. You are at much higher risk for CERTAIN cancers if you smoke. But, it's not just cancer, it's emphysema, COPD, etc. that can shorten your life, and not make the end years too fun. Not to mention the increased risk of heart disease.
So? This guy is 77. He already has cancer. He's lived a pretty full life. What difference does it make now?
Heck, what difference would it have made if my father had smoked? He died at 64 and it wasn't lung cancer. It's not likely a few cigs would have made his life much shorter.
Your comment was that it is a crapshoot, and it is not. Smoking CAN affect your lifespan.
__________________
LawyerLady
I can explain it to you, but I can't understand it for you.
Genetics can have a whole lot to do with what happens and how your body reacts to certain stimuli.
Grandma and grandpa didn't smoke. Both died in their 70s. They both dipped snuff. One had cancer of the mouth. One died of stroke nearly a decade after the first died.
Granny and pawpaw W. Pawpaw smoked a pipe now and then, granny didn't do anything. They died of old age. Both in their 90s.
Their kids, my granny R and pawpaw L. Pawpaw smoked all the time. Granny did not. He died at 78 from a stroke. Granny died at 78 from complications of brain cancer.
That is my dad's side of the family.
Mawmaw and pawpaw P. Neither smoked. Pawpaw died before I was born, diabetes. Mawmaw #1 died in child birth, mawmaw #2 died at 90 something.
Mawmaw and pawpaw U. Both smoked their whole life. They both stopped around the same time, about 10 years ago. Pawpaw died within 4 months of being diagnosed with cancer in every single cell of his body. Mawmaw will be 85 in Feb.
That is my mom's side.
All different stories. all going to end the same way. Dead.
__________________
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.
We don't know when we will die. We don't know what will be the cause of our death.
Yes. smoking is terrible for you.
But it doesn't matter how much a person says you should stop. Until you are ready. You wont. And when you do there is no guarantee you wont die anyway.
I remember a news story in which a person had just been told they had beat cancer. Walked outside the clinic to go celebrate and got hit by a car and died.
Something is going to kill you. Even it is just old age.
__________________
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.
We don't know when we will die. We don't know what will be the cause of our death.
Yes. smoking is terrible for you.
But it doesn't matter how much a person says you should stop. Until you are ready. You wont. And when you do there is no guarantee you wont die anyway.
I remember a news story in which a person had just been told they had beat cancer. Walked outside the clinic to go celebrate and got hit by a car and died.
Something is going to kill you. Even it is just old age.
I'm hoping for this last option. Where do I sign up?
__________________
The Principle of Least Interest: He who cares least about a relationship, controls it.
In my dads family there were 10 kids. Eight of his siblings either smoked or dipped snuff. All of the tobacco users have died from sort of cancer. Dad and one sister never used tobacco. Both are young looking and heathy for their actual ages of 77 and 80.
Dad said if he EVER caught me smoking, he'd make sure it would be the last time I smoked. Not sure what he planned to do, but I believed him. I have never smoked anything stronger than a bubble gum cigarette.
DH's mother smoked Lucky Strikes until her death from cancer. She was in her early 50's His father never smoked, yet he had "smokers lungs" and died few years after MIL. DH has asthma, which the drs attribute to all the smoke he was exposed to as a child. I'd feel terrible if I had contributed to my husband and son's health problems.
Add me to wanting to be on the dying from old age train.
In my dads family there were 10 kids. Eight of his siblings either smoked or dipped snuff. All of the tobacco users have died from sort of cancer. Dad and one sister never used tobacco. Both are young looking and heathy for their actual ages of 77 and 80.
Dad said if he EVER caught me smoking, he'd make sure it would be the last time I smoked. Not sure what he planned to do, but I believed him. I have never smoked anything stronger than a bubble gum cigarette.
DH's mother smoked Lucky Strikes until her death from cancer. She was in her early 50's His father never smoked, yet he had "smokers lungs" and died few years after MIL. DH has asthma, which the drs attribute to all the smoke he was exposed to as a child. I'd feel terrible if I had contributed to my husband and son's health problems.
Add me to wanting to be on the dying from old age train.
My mother has always lived in some sort of smoker's denial. Cigarette smoke makes my throat start to close up, I have a hard time breathing, and it gives me an instant headache. She calls me a hypochondriac about it - it can't possibly be true since I grew up around it.
__________________
LawyerLady
I can explain it to you, but I can't understand it for you.
My parents both smoked when I was growing up. Mama still smokes at least a pack a day, daddy smoked more. Its actually hard to find a picture of him without a cigarette in his hand.
I smoke, but have never had any issues. My sister has never smoked, and she doesn't either. Both my kids grew up with me and my ex smoking constantly. DD doesn't smoke at all DS does when he can afford to.
__________________
America guarantees equal opportunity, not equal outcome...
In my dads family there were 10 kids. Eight of his siblings either smoked or dipped snuff. All of the tobacco users have died from sort of cancer. Dad and one sister never used tobacco. Both are young looking and heathy for their actual ages of 77 and 80.
Dad said if he EVER caught me smoking, he'd make sure it would be the last time I smoked. Not sure what he planned to do, but I believed him. I have never smoked anything stronger than a bubble gum cigarette.
DH's mother smoked Lucky Strikes until her death from cancer. She was in her early 50's His father never smoked, yet he had "smokers lungs" and died few years after MIL. DH has asthma, which the drs attribute to all the smoke he was exposed to as a child. I'd feel terrible if I had contributed to my husband and son's health problems.
Add me to wanting to be on the dying from old age train.
My mother has always lived in some sort of smoker's denial. Cigarette smoke makes my throat start to close up, I have a hard time breathing, and it gives me an instant headache. She calls me a hypochondriac about it - it can't possibly be true since I grew up around it.
Your mother is an addict and in denial. (I was going to say your mother is something else, but decided that wasn't polite.)
I think one good response to this is "HOW DARE YOU!!!" if she ever says it again.
__________________
The Principle of Least Interest: He who cares least about a relationship, controls it.
I quit a 2 pack a day habit back in 1982. This was before all the cessation aids they now have. I threw out the cigarettes, gave up coffee (temporarily), took up needlework with a vengence. At the end of every day, I'd say to myself "Self, if you smoke tomorrow, you'll have to go through what today was like all over again." I did that every day for a month. Then DH asked me what I was going to do with all the money I wasn't spending on cigarettes (at the time they were about $8 a carton). He then calculated what a year's worth would cost, and told me to go buy something I wanted, and pay it out of my budget. So I got a new fangled microwave convection oven I'd been wishing for.
Paid it off, and still wasn't smoking. He then figured out 2 years worth...and we got a new bedroom set. This went on for years, and I think the last thing I bought was a Coleman tent camper.
My former habit would cost me at today's prices over $3500.
Some people have an easier time with nicotine withdrawal. Some don't. I will say that I still have very vivid dreams where I am smoking, even over 30 years later!
My father smoked two packs a day, starting when he was a teenager. He "quit" when he went into a nursing home and couldn't get them any more.
He died of "post-polio" syndrome at age 87.
My mother died at 67. She had a two millimeter lung tumor that spread to her brain. That led to brain surgery and death.
Some people will NOT get lung cancer or have heart attacks due to the effects of smoking. Most smokers WILL and DO get terminal illnesses from smoking.
So, in other words it's a crapshoot and all comes down to genetics, anyway.
No. You are at much higher risk for CERTAIN cancers if you smoke. But, it's not just cancer, it's emphysema, COPD, etc. that can shorten your life, and not make the end years too fun. Not to mention the increased risk of heart disease.
So? This guy is 77. He already has cancer. He's lived a pretty full life. What difference does it make now?
Heck, what difference would it have made if my father had smoked? He died at 64 and it wasn't lung cancer. It's not likely a few cigs would have made his life much shorter.
Your comment was that it is a crapshoot, and it is not. Smoking CAN affect your lifespan.
Maybe--maybe not--but so what? This guy is 77, not 47. How old do you really want to live to be, anyway? 77 is probably 5-10 years more than I'll have and I've never smoked.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.