Rights groups protested that the campaign portrayed indigenous Mexicans as inferior.
(Photo: YouTube)
Dec 6, 2015
In an ad distributed by Coca-Cola Mexico, pretty, young white people do their holiday good deed by bringing bottles of soda to a remote village and build a wooden Christmas tree in the town square. The “Open Your Heart” advertisement has been called anything but, as indigenous rights’ groups said the campaign promoted colonialism rather than unity.
“This type of publicity is an act of discrimination and racism,” Elvira Pablo, an indigenous lawyer, said at a press conference in Mexico City on Wednesday. “It is a comment on our type of life and an attempt to put a culture of consumerism in its place.”
After the ad was promoted on YouTube for about a week and then slammed on social media, Coca-cola pulled it on Tuesday—though other versions can be found online, one titled “The ‘White Savior’ Ad Coca-Cola Made Private.”
“Our intention was never to be insensitive to or underestimate any indigenous group,” a Coca-Cola spokesperson said in a statement to food news site Eater. “We have now removed the video and apologize to anyone who may have been offended.”
Silent but for a perky soundtrack, the video shows peppy fair-skinned actors bringing bottles of Coke to the Mixe people in Totontepec, a town in the southern state of Oaxaca.
Text in the video claims that 81.6 percent of Mexico’s indigenous people feel rejected for speaking a language other than Spanish, although it does not cite a source for the statistic. The ad ends with “#AbreTuCorazon” or “#OpenYourHeart.”
Related
The Coke-Funded Nonprofit That Pushed Exercise Over Diet Is No More
But instead of opening hearts, Pablo and other activists said the ad “reproduced and reinforced stereotypes of indigenous people as culturally and racially subordinate,” according to a report in The Guardian, which reported that they have asked the government to sanction the soft drink giant.
The Alliance for Food Health has filed an official complaint with the National Council to Prevent Discrimination. Mexico is one of the most obese nations on the planet and a top consumer of soda—although the nation's soda tax has seen some progress in reducing sales.
To counteract Coca-Cola’s message, the Alliance for Food Health created its own video, including Mixe people speaking about the soda industry’s influence on their community.
“Fifty years ago, cases of diabetes type 2 in our indigenous communities were rare,” says one person, speaking in the Mixe language. “Now they begin to be an epidemic. In order to remain united, we must preserve our dignity, our health, and our culture. In Oaxaca, we drink tejare, tea and clean water.”
__________________
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou
I know a few people from this area/culture.
And they don't feel isolated from people who speak English, or Americans, they feel isolated from people who speak exclusively Spanish, ie, OTHER MEXICANS.
This ad is ridiculous and pointless. It needed Latino actors, not white ones, to make aNY sort of sense at all.
So, someone trying to be nice to another and giving them a Coke is now "racism". You can't make this stuff up. How ridiculous the world is becoming. Just by being white, no matter what you do, it is "racism".
Well, then we need to stop sending all Humanitarian aid to foreign countries. We wouldn't want to be accused of being their "white Savior". Let them fend for themselves.
All of it was ridiculous. Claiming that no matter what a white person does it is seen as racist, that sharing a coke is wrong, that isn't what I was talking about AT ALL.
And yeah. The video is pointless.
All of it was ridiculous. Claiming that no matter what a white person does it is seen as racist, that sharing a coke is wrong, that isn't what I was talking about AT ALL. And yeah. The video is pointless.
I didn't say that YOU said that. That is what the article is saying and the response to it.
I think this is overblown - it certainly doesn't reach the level of "offensive". Doesn't everyone remember the "I'd like to give the world a Coke" campaign?
__________________
LawyerLady
I can explain it to you, but I can't understand it for you.
If the PEOPLE PORTRAYED IN THE VIDEO find it offensive, I don't see how you claim otherwise.
Racial undertones exist. They are a thing. The rich happy white people bringing culture to the poor savage heathens!
Nope.
If the PEOPLE PORTRAYED IN THE VIDEO find it offensive, I don't see how you claim otherwise. Racial undertones exist. They are a thing. The rich happy white people bringing culture to the poor savage heathens! Nope.
Well fine. Then we rich happy whites can stop sending foreign and humitarian aid to them so we dont' 'offend" them. Suits me.
If the PEOPLE PORTRAYED IN THE VIDEO find it offensive, I don't see how you claim otherwise. Racial undertones exist. They are a thing. The rich happy white people bringing culture to the poor savage heathens! Nope.
It is highly doubtful the people portrayed in the video have seen the ad.
__________________
LawyerLady
I can explain it to you, but I can't understand it for you.
If the PEOPLE PORTRAYED IN THE VIDEO find it offensive, I don't see how you claim otherwise. Racial undertones exist. They are a thing. The rich happy white people bringing culture to the poor savage heathens! Nope.
It is highly doubtful the people portrayed in the video have seen the ad.
Right?
So, if I find something offensive, everyone has to agree that's its offensive?
__________________
America guarantees equal opportunity, not equal outcome...
If the PEOPLE PORTRAYED IN THE VIDEO find it offensive, I don't see how you claim otherwise. Racial undertones exist. They are a thing. The rich happy white people bringing culture to the poor savage heathens! Nope.
Well fine. Then we rich happy whites can stop sending foreign and humitarian aid to them so we dont' 'offend" them. Suits me.
Me, too.
Peopel are damned for being wealthy and not sharing it, but if they do, then it's now racist, apparently.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.
If the PEOPLE PORTRAYED IN THE VIDEO find it offensive, I don't see how you claim otherwise. Racial undertones exist. They are a thing. The rich happy white people bringing culture to the poor savage heathens! Nope.
It is highly doubtful the people portrayed in the video have seen the ad.
Right?
So, if I find something offensive, everyone has to agree that's its offensive?
Yes. That's how it works. If someone says 'I AM OFFENDED", then the whole damn world is supposed to stop and fawn all over their butthurt ass.
it's a soft-drink commercial--grow up and get the hell over it
Hey, I'm offended by that! j/k Yeah, they really do need to grow up and get over it.
__________________
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou