Q. Boundaries after a favor: Last year, with the help of family and friends, I extricated myself from a physically and emotionally abusive marriage. It was the most difficult thing I’ve ever done. I understand that I’m lucky to have had relatives who were able to help me with legal fees and moving expenses (I’m on a payment plan and have repaid almost all of it by now), but now my family members make unreasonable demands for personal information about me, require I check in with them about decisions I’m making for myself, and have implied that I shouldn’t spend money on certain items (necessities like rent) until I’ve paid them back. They’ve gone so far as to repeatedly call and text me when I’m at work until I drop everything (even leaving meetings!) to answer whatever their questions may be. They make hurtful comments about how my past judgment was clearly not the best to have ended up in a relationship with an abuser and I can’t be trusted to make decisions for myself yet. They also say that I’m ungrateful, which couldn’t be further from the truth. I’ve worked hard in therapy to understand how important boundaries are to recovering from past abuse, and this dynamic feels unhealthy for me. I’m hesitant, however, to be rude to family members who likely saved my life and seem to really be doing this out of a misplaced sense of caring. How do I balance my obligation to their generosity with my obligation to myself?
A: Implying that you have no right to pay your own rent and aren’t capable of caring for yourself because you have been abused in the past sounds an awful lot like abuse to me. I’m so sorry that you’ve managed to escape one abusive living situation only to find yourself being manipulated and berated by your would-be saviors. I’m glad to hear you’ve almost finished your payment plan, because the sooner you are no longer financially beholden to these people, the better.
In the meantime, I think it’s more than fair for you to tell them that although you’re grateful they were able to lend you money, you will not be able to answer calls while you are at work and will have to get back to them at the end of the day. You are under no obligation to give them personal information or listen to them question your judgment. They think you owe them your life; all you owe them is money.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
Unfortunately, she owes them money. Undoubtedly she desperately needed it to get out of whatever bad situation she was in, but now she's kind of in another bad situation that's not so easy to see clear of.
I think her only real strategy is to avoid them as much as possible and pay the money back as soon as possible. After that, she won't be beholden to them and will have more options both in what she can say to them and do.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
Demanding she leave meetings at work is just going to get her fired. Do they not see that? These people are over the top.
__________________
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou
She needs to set some boundaries and be firm with them. Also pay off the debt as quickly as possible. I also wouldn't be opposed to her calling them out on thinking that she owes them anything more than the money she borrowed.
Instruct whomever answers to phone at work to take messages and don't return them until after hours.
And she is going to have draw a clear line with these people once the debt is paid.
__________________
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.
She is seeing a therapist. Why didn't she talk to the therapist about these awful people instead of writing into an advice column?! The therapist would undoubtedly tell her that the reason she chose that awful partner was because her family has taught her that is how she deserves to be treated. Since they treat her the same and all.
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
She is seeing a therapist. Why didn't she talk to the therapist about these awful people instead of writing into an advice column?! The therapist would undoubtedly tell her that the reason she chose that awful partner was because her family has taught her that is how she deserves to be treated. Since they treat her the same and all.
I thought the same thing. She left a controlling manipulative family to be with a controlling abusive man.
__________________
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.
Instruct whomever answers to phone at work to take messages and don't return them until after hours.
And she is going to have draw a clear line with these people once the debt is paid.
Answering personal calls or texts during work is totally her choice, and a poor one. If she loses her job over it, that is on her, not the family. She clearly doesn't know how to set boundaries.
__________________
Sometimes you're the windshield, and sometimes you're the bug.
It would appear she cannot set boundaries for herself, hence, she is once again, a victim. As long as she continues to pay off her debts, they have nothing to complain about, and she needs to point this out and drop it.
They helped you out. You are now back on your feet. Work overtime and pay them back. If you owe someone money and fail to pay them back, it pisses them off. Pay them back.
Ok, I've changed my mind somewhat. She may be constantly needing help from her relatives and so they are tired of it. They know it will always fall on them to help her out of whatever the latest problem is so may be giving her a dose of tough love. I do have a relative that always is making poor choices and needs help so I get why the relatives may want to make sure it doesn't happen again. If that is the case they need to cut off the money train.
__________________
Sometimes you're the windshield, and sometimes you're the bug.
When my mom moved to town, as an elderly widow, a man living in a neighboring apartment befriended her. He was quite younger but he seemed to be a decent guy and she would cook for him. I wasn't entirely happy about it but he was good company. Anyway i found out that he "borrowed" $400 from her. And, then he went and bought a new car. So, I got on his damn case. Then he sent me a check that bounced. So, i called him in a very pissed off state. I got paid back the next day. Makes me wonder how else he scammed my mom.
However, i digress. As for helping relatives, my BIL got into a bad position and called us for help. We decided to send them some money and told them that it was a gift. I dont' loan money. Loaning money changes relationships so no thanks. Anyway, they did thank us. SHortly after that they arrived at our house with a ridiculous amount of Christmas gifts for our 3 kids. That was ridiculous. Money problems and you are buying this kind of crap? Um no. They called again and wanted help paying their daughter's college tuition. No can do.
When my mom moved to town, as an elderly widow, a man living in a neighboring apartment befriended her. He was quite younger but he seemed to be a decent guy and she would cook for him. I wasn't entirely happy about it but he was good company. Anyway i found out that he "borrowed" $400 from her. And, then he went and bought a new car. So, I got on his damn case. Then he sent me a check that bounced. So, i called him in a very pissed off state. I got paid back the next day. Makes me wonder how else he scammed my mom. However, i digress. As for helping relatives, my BIL got into a bad position and called us for help. We decided to send them some money and told them that it was a gift. I dont' loan money. Loaning money changes relationships so no thanks. Anyway, they did thank us. SHortly after that they arrived at our house with a ridiculous amount of Christmas gifts for our 3 kids. That was ridiculous. Money problems and you are buying this kind of crap? Um no. They called again and wanted help paying their daughter's college tuition. No can do.
But wait, I thought it was her money and she could do whatever she wanted with it. That seemed to be your argument on another thread.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
When my mom moved to town, as an elderly widow, a man living in a neighboring apartment befriended her. He was quite younger but he seemed to be a decent guy and she would cook for him. I wasn't entirely happy about it but he was good company. Anyway i found out that he "borrowed" $400 from her. And, then he went and bought a new car. So, I got on his damn case. Then he sent me a check that bounced. So, i called him in a very pissed off state. I got paid back the next day. Makes me wonder how else he scammed my mom. However, i digress. As for helping relatives, my BIL got into a bad position and called us for help. We decided to send them some money and told them that it was a gift. I dont' loan money. Loaning money changes relationships so no thanks. Anyway, they did thank us. SHortly after that they arrived at our house with a ridiculous amount of Christmas gifts for our 3 kids. That was ridiculous. Money problems and you are buying this kind of crap? Um no. They called again and wanted help paying their daughter's college tuition. No can do.
But wait, I thought it was her money and she could do whatever she wanted with it. That seemed to be your argument on another thread.
Yes. She did what she wanted. But he still had to pay her back. Not sure what your point is.
When my mom moved to town, as an elderly widow, a man living in a neighboring apartment befriended her. He was quite younger but he seemed to be a decent guy and she would cook for him. I wasn't entirely happy about it but he was good company. Anyway i found out that he "borrowed" $400 from her. And, then he went and bought a new car. So, I got on his damn case. Then he sent me a check that bounced. So, i called him in a very pissed off state. I got paid back the next day. Makes me wonder how else he scammed my mom. However, i digress. As for helping relatives, my BIL got into a bad position and called us for help. We decided to send them some money and told them that it was a gift. I dont' loan money. Loaning money changes relationships so no thanks. Anyway, they did thank us. SHortly after that they arrived at our house with a ridiculous amount of Christmas gifts for our 3 kids. That was ridiculous. Money problems and you are buying this kind of crap? Um no. They called again and wanted help paying their daughter's college tuition. No can do.
But wait, I thought it was her money and she could do whatever she wanted with it. That seemed to be your argument on another thread.
Yes. She did what she wanted. But he still had to pay her back. Not sure what your point is.
The point is that you flip out when I suggest getting involved witth a parent's finances, but when you do so then it's ok.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
No, you want to tell your capable adult parents how they should spend every dime they have as if they are 3 yrs old because they are over 60. Big difference.
No, you want to tell your capable adult parents how they should spend every dime they have as if they are 3 yrs old because they are over 60. Big difference.
Yet you got involved here. SAME THING.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
You latch on to one nuanced comment that someone has said 5 years ago and try to spin things into something they aren't and never were. You have issues.
You latch on to one nuanced comment that someone has said 5 years ago and try to spin things into something they aren't and never were. You have issues.
It was only a few months ago. The situation was very similar. You said people should not intervene even if their parents are getting scammed. Now, you were worried about this guy scamming your parent and so yiu intervened to get her $400 back.
hypocrite
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
You latch on to one nuanced comment that someone has said 5 years ago and try to spin things into something they aren't and never were. You have issues.
It was only a few months ago. The situation was very similar. You said people should not intervene even if their parents are getting scammed. Now, you were worried about this guy scamming your parent and so yiu intervened to get her $400 back.
hypocrite
That isn't what I said but whatever. Go get your jollies off.
And she didn't tell the therapist about it because she doesn't want to hear the truth. It would hurt too much.
I get the feeling she did tell the therapist and feels the therapist's advice was maybe too harsh (from her 'not wanting to be rude' comment) and wrote here for another opinion or for validation that she can do what the therapist said.
My parents helped me many years ago but I had to start enforcing boundaries when many years later and I was doing just fine they still thought they had ownership in my choices.
Dad especially. I did alot of phone call screening.
She doesnt have to keep explaining her life as long as she is paying them. She doesn't have to answer the phone either.
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou
I was being facetious. Definitely shouldn't start dating.
__________________
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou
But seriously, it doesn't sound like she's ready to start dating yet.
Just getting out of an abusive marriage, and all.
But, her family doesn't sound much better, to me.
She needs to pay them off, ASAP.
And get out from under their unreasonable demands.
The debt doesn't stop with paying the money back from what I gather. The debt includes the posse running in and saving her apparently. Maybe it's well founded. The posse needs to decide whether to keep helping her or not and stop demanding more than the loans repaid, and LW needs to set boundaries.
__________________
Sometimes you're the windshield, and sometimes you're the bug.
Of course I am. When I suggested that children should intervene to prevent their parents from being victims of fraud--you said it was "their money" and that they shouldn't interfere.
Now when it was your mother, you said exactly the opposite.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
No but it was about an older lady giving money to a tv preacher.
__________________
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou