totallygeeked -> totallygeeked general -> You're not providing for your family... I am!' The shocking moment a Walmart customer launches a foul-mouthed tirade
Post Info
TOPIC: You're not providing for your family... I am!' The shocking moment a Walmart customer launches a foul-mouthed tirade
'You're not providing for your family... I am!' The shocking moment a Walmart customer launches a foul-mouthed tirade at a man in front of his young son for paying with food stamps
Video caught the woman shamed the man, who was using food stamps at a local Walmart
When the man said he works 50-60 hours a week trying to provide for his family, she retorted, 'You're not providing... I am!'
The pair argue, with the man telling her to vote Republican if she doesn't like it, and her snapping that he must be a Bernie Sanders supporter
PUBLISHED: 17:40 EST, 4 May 2016 | UPDATED: 01:44 EST, 5 May 2016
A woman has been shamed after being caught on camera launching into an expletive-laden rant at a man for using food stamps in a Walmart.
According to the video's poster on YouTube, the woman spotted the man in front of her paying with a food stamps card.
She then told her young son: 'See, this is why you go to college, so you don't take handouts.'
This sparked an argument, with the man saying: 'You know, I put in 50-60 hour weeks trying to provide for my family' as his young son sat in a grocery cart next to him.
The uploader of the video pointed out that the man was using a 'W.I.C.' or 'Women, Infants, and Children' card to buy products for his son in the store, somewhere in the US.
Shocking: The unidentified woman berated the young father in front of her for using food stamps to pay for his food at a Walmart
+5
+5
The man, whose son is in a grocery cart next to him, tells her that he works 50 to 60 hours a week, but needs to provide for his family - the woman counters that he isn't, that she is, since the money for food stamps comes out of her paycheck
'You’re not providing for it, I am!' the woman retorted. 'The government is.'
'You're not,' he said.
'They take it out of my check,' she insisted. 'Bulls*** they don't.'
When the man tells her to complain to her local Senator or to vote Republican, she replies,'Oh, trust me, I am not a bleeding heart f**king liberal. That ain't gonna happen.'
The man finally turns away from her, shoves his hands in his pockets, and says: 'I don't care about you lady, shut the f*** up.
+5
Many expletives are exchanged during the heated argument, in which the man tells her to complain to her senator if she doesn't like the rules, and she says he must be a Bernie Sanders supporter
'I don't have to, it's a free country, remember?' she retorts. Then she tells him he must be a Bernie Sanders supporter. 'That's who you vote for. They give it to you, so you vote that way.'
When the man says something unintelligible, and even starts to laugh a little, she says, 'I have a degree. I am pretty damn smart.'
They exchange more words and then the man says, 'Mind your own business. Vote Republican and get 'em out of there. Until then, deal with it, b*tch.'
When the man says, 'I don't make the rules, lady,' she replies, 'No, you just take advantage of them like everyone else.'
'Why wouldn't I?' he asks, getting out his wallet.
The video has been viewed almost three million times since it was uploaded on April 24. It's unclear which city the heated exchange took place in.
A 2014 report found that Walmart, where the video subjects were shopping, costs taxpayers $6.2billion a year in food stamps, subsidized housing, Medicaid, and other forms of public assistance because of the low wages it pays its employees, according to the group Americans for Tax Fairness.
'A single Walmart Supercenter cost taxpayers between $904,542 and $1.75 million per year, or between $3,015 and $5,815 on average for each of 300 workers,' said the report, entitled 'How Americans Subsidize America's Biggest Employer and Richest Family.'
The report found that Walmart also collected almost 18 percent of the food stamp market in 2013.
+5
The altercation between a young man on food stamps and a woman who shamed him over it took place at an unidentified Walmart - a company that has been found to cost taxpayers $6.2billion a year in public assistance because of the low wages it pays its employees, according to a 2014 report by Americans for Tax Fairness
You know, if the guy is truly working that many hours, I really don't mind if he needs the food stamps, he is trying. However I would hope he is not buying crap food.
__________________
Sometimes you're the windshield, and sometimes you're the bug.
You know, a long, long time ago, in a land far way, MEN used to have a sense of Pride and Honor and taking govt handouts was something they would not have done. However, the fault doesnt' lie with people who can't get jobs. What jobs? Govt has destroyed our industries, shut down our energy sector, coal miners are losing their jobs right and left and the only jobs left are fast food. So, just another example of why we need to elect Trump to revitalize our economy so people can get jobs.
You know, a long, long time ago, in a land far way, MEN used to have a sense of Pride and Honor and taking govt handouts was something they would not have done. However, the fault doesnt' lie with people who can't get jobs. What jobs? Govt has destroyed our industries, shut down our energy sector, coal miners are losing their jobs right and left and the only jobs left are fast food. So, just another example of why we need to elect Trump to revitalize our economy so people can get jobs.
Lol! The Trump who said "China is stealing our jobs?" That Trump?
You know, a long, long time ago, in a land far way, MEN used to have a sense of Pride and Honor and taking govt handouts was something they would not have done. However, the fault doesnt' lie with people who can't get jobs. What jobs? Govt has destroyed our industries, shut down our energy sector, coal miners are losing their jobs right and left and the only jobs left are fast food. So, just another example of why we need to elect Trump to revitalize our economy so people can get jobs.
Lol! The Trump who said "China is stealing our jobs?" That Trump?
Yep same one. Same business owner who is the same as many others that to make money, or shut down, had to go overseas for cheap labor due to all the gov't taxes and regulations that drives the high cost of doing business in this country. Yep the person who has experience with the ramifications of ridiculous gov't over reach, that one.
__________________
Sometimes you're the windshield, and sometimes you're the bug.
Yeah, the one who actually has run a business, hired employees and run a payroll. The one who has had business failures and business successes. The one who is not a professional politician glomming off society with lies political BS. That one.
You know, a long, long time ago, in a land far way, MEN used to have a sense of Pride and Honor and taking govt handouts was something they would not have done. However, the fault doesnt' lie with people who can't get jobs. What jobs? Govt has destroyed our industries, shut down our energy sector, coal miners are losing their jobs right and left and the only jobs left are fast food. So, just another example of why we need to elect Trump to revitalize our economy so people can get jobs.
Unemployment is so low here that companies are struggling to get people. It's not doom and gloom everywhere. There are so many people hiring here it's ridiculous - jobs from cashiers to professional jobs. We can't find people to work our open positions and they aren't entry level jobs.
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
I disagree. He is working. That's a huge start. It may not pay enough now, but if he works hard and betters himself, he will earn more. This is the type of person we shouldn't mind supporting - people who are working to do better.
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
You know, a long, long time ago, in a land far way, MEN used to have a sense of Pride and Honor and taking govt handouts was something they would not have done. However, the fault doesnt' lie with people who can't get jobs. What jobs? Govt has destroyed our industries, shut down our energy sector, coal miners are losing their jobs right and left and the only jobs left are fast food. So, just another example of why we need to elect Trump to revitalize our economy so people can get jobs.
You know, a long, long time ago, in a land far way, MEN used to have a sense of Pride and Honor and taking govt handouts was something they would not have done. However, the fault doesnt' lie with people who can't get jobs. What jobs? Govt has destroyed our industries, shut down our energy sector, coal miners are losing their jobs right and left and the only jobs left are fast food. So, just another example of why we need to elect Trump to revitalize our economy so people can get jobs.
Just because the guy SAYS he is working 40-50 hour weeks, doesn't mean that he IS, either. When I was young and pregnant, I couldn't get any help with my pregnancy (I was uninsured) because I made too much money at $6.50/hour for a full time job. So I have a hard time believing he is actually working that many hours and is still eligible for assistance.
Well, let's say he works as a meat packer for $15 an hour (giving the benefit of a higher wage), that's $600 a week for 40 hours, plus $270 for an extra 12 hours each week (assume 52 hours a week at time and a half for the overtime).
He makes $870 a week. That's $45,240.00 a year assuming 52 weeks of work or $3770.00 a month. He would need to have a family of 7 to get food stamps.
Income Chart
(Oct. 1, 2015 through Sept. 30, 2016)
Household size
Gross monthly income (130 percent of poverty)
Net monthly income (100 percent of poverty)
1
$1,276
$ 981
2
1,726
1,328
3
2,177
1,675
4
2,628
2,021
5
3,078
2,368
6
3,529
2,715
7
3,980
3,061
8
4,430
3,408
Each additional member
+451
+347
Now, of course, if he's only making $11 an hour, then, assuming the same hours, he's only making $33,176.00 a year, or $2,765.67 a month, and a family of 5 would be eligible.
__________________
LawyerLady
I can explain it to you, but I can't understand it for you.
What enrages me so much about these things is that people always assume it is a conservative republican that is doing the stupid ranting and yelling at the person on welfare. *I* am a conservative republican who has BEEN on welfare and know FIRST HAND what it is like and do not condone the overhanded behavior at all. People need to burn their judgy mc judging pants and think outside of their little minds to realize that perception is NOT reality.
Well, let's say he works as a meat packer for $15 an hour (giving the benefit of a higher wage), that's $600 a week for 40 hours, plus $270 for an extra 12 hours each week (assume 52 hours a week at time and a half for the overtime).
He makes $870 a week. That's $45,240.00 a year assuming 52 weeks of work or $3770.00 a month. He would need to have a family of 7 to get food stamps.
Income Chart
(Oct. 1, 2015 through Sept. 30, 2016)
Household size
Gross monthly income (130 percent of poverty)
Net monthly income (100 percent of poverty)
1
$1,276
$ 981
2
1,726
1,328
3
2,177
1,675
4
2,628
2,021
5
3,078
2,368
6
3,529
2,715
7
3,980
3,061
8
4,430
3,408
Each additional member
+451
+347
Now, of course, if he's only making $11 an hour, then, assuming the same hours, he's only making $33,176.00 a year, or $2,765.67 a month, and a family of 5 would be eligible.
And he had only one kid with him--so maybe only a family of three. Plus, what's his wife doing?
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
You know, a long, long time ago, in a land far way, MEN used to have a sense of Pride and Honor and taking govt handouts was something they would not have done. However, the fault doesnt' lie with people who can't get jobs. What jobs? Govt has destroyed our industries, shut down our energy sector, coal miners are losing their jobs right and left and the only jobs left are fast food. So, just another example of why we need to elect Trump to revitalize our economy so people can get jobs.
Be grateful you live in Canada, my friend.
flan
Why? Do Canadian men lack pride and self sufficiency?
Well, let's say he works as a meat packer for $15 an hour (giving the benefit of a higher wage), that's $600 a week for 40 hours, plus $270 for an extra 12 hours each week (assume 52 hours a week at time and a half for the overtime).
He makes $870 a week. That's $45,240.00 a year assuming 52 weeks of work or $3770.00 a month. He would need to have a family of 7 to get food stamps.
Income Chart
(Oct. 1, 2015 through Sept. 30, 2016)
Household size
Gross monthly income (130 percent of poverty)
Net monthly income (100 percent of poverty)
1
$1,276
$ 981
2
1,726
1,328
3
2,177
1,675
4
2,628
2,021
5
3,078
2,368
6
3,529
2,715
7
3,980
3,061
8
4,430
3,408
Each additional member
+451
+347
Now, of course, if he's only making $11 an hour, then, assuming the same hours, he's only making $33,176.00 a year, or $2,765.67 a month, and a family of 5 would be eligible.
If he makes $7.25/hr x60 hrs, that's $435 a week or $22, 620 per year. Why would you assume $15 an hour?
Well, let's say he works as a meat packer for $15 an hour (giving the benefit of a higher wage), that's $600 a week for 40 hours, plus $270 for an extra 12 hours each week (assume 52 hours a week at time and a half for the overtime).
He makes $870 a week. That's $45,240.00 a year assuming 52 weeks of work or $3770.00 a month. He would need to have a family of 7 to get food stamps.
Income Chart
(Oct. 1, 2015 through Sept. 30, 2016)
Household size
Gross monthly income (130 percent of poverty)
Net monthly income (100 percent of poverty)
1
$1,276
$ 981
2
1,726
1,328
3
2,177
1,675
4
2,628
2,021
5
3,078
2,368
6
3,529
2,715
7
3,980
3,061
8
4,430
3,408
Each additional member
+451
+347
Now, of course, if he's only making $11 an hour, then, assuming the same hours, he's only making $33,176.00 a year, or $2,765.67 a month, and a family of 5 would be eligible.
If he makes $7.25/hr x60 hrs, that's $435 a week or $22, 620 per year. Why would you assume $15 an hour?
good God. Why wouldn't he? He's a grown man. Most kids I know make more than that. My son makes almost 15 And he's been doing his job for less than a year.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
Well, let's say he works as a meat packer for $15 an hour (giving the benefit of a higher wage), that's $600 a week for 40 hours, plus $270 for an extra 12 hours each week (assume 52 hours a week at time and a half for the overtime).
He makes $870 a week. That's $45,240.00 a year assuming 52 weeks of work or $3770.00 a month. He would need to have a family of 7 to get food stamps.
Income Chart
(Oct. 1, 2015 through Sept. 30, 2016)
Household size
Gross monthly income (130 percent of poverty)
Net monthly income (100 percent of poverty)
1
$1,276
$ 981
2
1,726
1,328
3
2,177
1,675
4
2,628
2,021
5
3,078
2,368
6
3,529
2,715
7
3,980
3,061
8
4,430
3,408
Each additional member
+451
+347
Now, of course, if he's only making $11 an hour, then, assuming the same hours, he's only making $33,176.00 a year, or $2,765.67 a month, and a family of 5 would be eligible.
If he makes $7.25/hr x60 hrs, that's $435 a week or $22, 620 per year. Why would you assume $15 an hour?
good God. Why wouldn't he? He's a grown man. Most kids I know make more than that. My son makes almost 15 And he's been doing his job for less than a year.
So what? Not everyone makes a decent wage Husker. There are a lot of minimum wage jobs, yes. But, even at 60 hrs that isnt much.
Not a lot of areas have jobs that start out at more than minimum wage. In my hometown, most jobs are $10 an hour or less. And those are factory jobs too. To assume he makes $15 is kind of insane. I worked a skilled job in accounting and made less than $15 an hour. Now I had amazing time off benefits and a flex schedule so it worked at the time. But I don't know of a job in my hometown that starts out at that rate.
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
He looks young. Is he raising the child himself? Day care can be $200 a week. Then the other expenses of daily living on top of it can take every cent.
I see a guy with a kid trying to be a father.
He is having a hard time making ends meet.
The foul mouthed woman needs her trap punched.
__________________
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.
I just searched jobs in my hometown. I found nothing for over $10/Hr. Forklift operator needed to work 12 hour days - starts at $9.50/hr. Warehouse laborer, same pay. Lumberyard sales associate - $10/hr. Campground facilities technician - minimum wage.
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.
There for a while, I would have been literally working for nothing.
Child care and gas would have been more than I made.
__________________
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.
If trump creates jobs will Americans do them, or only if the wage goes up.
The consenus is that China is making literally everything. And, we can't run an economy on fast food jobs. So, if we actually return to a county of Production, then wages will go up and yes Americans will do those jobs.
I just searched jobs in my hometown. I found nothing for over $10/Hr. Forklift operator needed to work 12 hour days - starts at $9.50/hr. Warehouse laborer, same pay. Lumberyard sales associate - $10/hr. Campground facilities technician - minimum wage.
That can't be right.
__________________
LawyerLady
I can explain it to you, but I can't understand it for you.
He looks young. Is he raising the child himself? Day care can be $200 a week. Then the other expenses of daily living on top of it can take every cent.
I see a guy with a kid trying to be a father.
He is having a hard time making ends meet.
The foul mouthed woman needs her trap punched.
I agree.
__________________
LawyerLady
I can explain it to you, but I can't understand it for you.
He looks young. Is he raising the child himself? Day care can be $200 a week. Then the other expenses of daily living on top of it can take every cent.
I see a guy with a kid trying to be a father.
He is having a hard time making ends meet.
The foul mouthed woman needs her trap punched.
I agree.
Considering it was Wal-Mart, I'm surprised no one did!
I just searched jobs in my hometown. I found nothing for over $10/Hr. Forklift operator needed to work 12 hour days - starts at $9.50/hr. Warehouse laborer, same pay. Lumberyard sales associate - $10/hr. Campground facilities technician - minimum wage.
That can't be right.
Why not? Here in a major market, they wanted to pay DH, a skilled IT Network Specialist $10/hour.
Minimum wage here in PA is $7.25 unless you are a waiter/waitress. An employer may pay a minimum of $2.83 per hour to an employee who makes $30.00 per month in tips. The employer must make up the difference if the tips and $2.83 do not meet the regular Pennsylvania minimum wage. But most employers do not make up the difference. $2.83/hour is less than $115 per week. If that person makes only $30 a month in tips, that is not even $130/week and the employer does not have to make up anything. Granted, that would have to be a sucky waitperson and a really sucky job that I would not stay at.
I just searched jobs in my hometown. I found nothing for over $10/Hr. Forklift operator needed to work 12 hour days - starts at $9.50/hr. Warehouse laborer, same pay. Lumberyard sales associate - $10/hr. Campground facilities technician - minimum wage.
That can't be right.
Lol. Well it is. I searched the want ads in my hometown and that's what I found. $15/hr jobs are really hard to find there (and a lot of other places as well). Further searching showed that for some jobs, they wanted a college education but were offering $12/hr. That's ridiculous. But that's the market in a lot of areas.
And if you read the poster's comments about the original video, the man was using WIC. That is a program made especially for people who are working and have a low income. He was not using EBT/SNAP. It was WIC which is specifically for the working poor and they can only purchase nutritious food with it. So I think we need to relax a bit on the judgement.
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
I don't think we need to relax judgment. The govt has created this situation by turning a huge blind eye to welfare fraud and corruption. To them it is simply buying a vote and they dont' care who gets it. So, they have no incentive to care one way or the other and it is obvious that they don't. Americans are a very generous people and nation. But, so many are sick to death of the scammers and cheats and lazy lard butts that think they are entitled to be supported all of their lives without a lick of effort on their part. So, yeah, judgment? Too darn bad. And, so once in awhile someone who legitimately uses it gets caught in the crossfire. But nobody is allowed to complain about the waste and fraud.
I know a lot of people who barely make $10 to $15 an hour. So, if you want to belittle them you may. But, we have a lot of service positions at the school and they start at $9.25. Eventually they make up to $12 or so but that is after years.
There are lots of jobs locally that are minimum wage or about $10 per hour. My son was just offered a job, who is graduating in June with a 2 yr associate's in electrical/building construction for exactly $10 an hour. It was out of town and we would have to move him there and get an apt and it really didn't sound like a job with much potential so we told him to turn it down and look for other jobs. Yes, if he gets a $10 locally, then maybe he can start with that, but degreed people aren't making a whole lot more than that.
The reality is that economy sucks. Obama can spin his numbers. Yeah, there are micro economies in some places that are doing well or OK. But, across America, that simply is not the case.
You can complain about the waste and fraud all you want. I do too. But don't judge someone who is using the program as it was intended - for people who earn too much to get SNAP but could still use some help. I have zero problem helping someone who has a job. He is the type of person we should be helping! Encouraging him to continue working and not give up! Help fill the gap! But the welfare fraud is not his problem. Why take it out on him?!
If you want to judge people using SNAP and buying crap food, go for it. If you want to judge them for not working, well that's on you, I don't know their story. But this guy is doing the right thing. Don't blame him for all the welfare fraud.
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
And, you are the one saying there are tons of good jobs to be had where you live. Sounds like you are pronouncing your judgment.
Where I live there are a ton of great jobs to be had. But my hometown is the total opposite. I am not judging anyone.
When I was talking about "blaming him" I was referring to your comment about how you would not relax judgement. You started your post with that sentence. I thought you were referring to judging him.
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
totallygeeked -> totallygeeked general -> You're not providing for your family... I am!' The shocking moment a Walmart customer launches a foul-mouthed tirade