I do agree that when bullying happens... the bully should be the one forced to leave school.
I agree. Bullies are usually good at covering their tracks though. This is where the social media aspect is a good thing- since there is proof. With a lot of bullying it would just be he said-she said.
No one can control what happens, only limit where it happens as much as possible.
If schools make it 100% impossible on school grounds (not that that's likely... but... work with me here), the bullying will just happen on the way home from school or on the way too school. or in the McDonald's the first time they see the person they want to bully there.
and this is where parents, bystanders and society at large need to step in. It takes a village to raise a child and we all have a hand. If I'm at McD's (okay, I'll admit that I am not usually at McDs) and see a group of kids picking on one? I'll step in. I would expect others to as well.
Bingo! As long as we make excuses and look the other way we can't expect anything to change.
I agree. I agree with what Husker is saying too. When it comes to my kid I'm not hanging her happiness on hoping other people do the right thing.
DD's school seems to do a good job- there is a lot more focus than when I was in school anyway. There is a constant dialogue, they get the kids involved, and encourage them to reach out to other kids or step in if a kid is being picked on. She is only in elementary school though, so I'm not sure how well those same approaches would work for older kids.
I actually think it's harder for kids in high school. Whether they're ready or not we expect them to deal with stuff that even some adults have a really hard time with.
__________________
“Until I discovered cooking, I was never really interested in anything.” ― Julia Child ―
I did not see a single person on this thread who said we should ignore or not punish bullies. But we used to teach our kids " sticks and stones can break ny bones but names can never hurt me" and I think that little saying was a very effective tool and I remember kids yelling that back at bulliies. It was one small way of empowering kids.
Yes we have... It's me... RichardInTN. Long time no chat!
Why do I know this name? Have we met? If not nice to meet you TOC!
If nothing else, you might remember me as the "creator" of the "Junk Drawer" on GT... it survived LONG after my removal.
No. It's not that. I've heard you're name here and I think you're a black sheep or something like that...lol
Ohh... I believe I have seen my name mentioned a time or two since this board's inception. Not really a black sheep (naturally) per se... more like a sheep that's been spray-painted black by others.
-- Edited by Truth-or-Consequences on Saturday 6th of December 2014 11:30:36 PM
Yes we have... It's me... RichardInTN. Long time no chat!
Why do I know this name? Have we met? If not nice to meet you TOC!
If nothing else, you might remember me as the "creator" of the "Junk Drawer" on GT... it survived LONG after my removal.
No. It's not that. I've heard you're name here and I think you're a black sheep or something like that...lol
Ohh... I believe I have seen my name mentioned a time or two since this board's inception. Not really a black sheep (naturally) per se... more like a sheep that's been spray-painted black by others.
-- Edited by Truth-or-Consequences on Saturday 6th of December 2014 11:19:19 PM
And, um, separated from the flock, if I recall correctly . . .
LOL... naaah... was moderating/posting on another board I'm a moderator on... so I disappeared from the little green men because I was gone more than whatever their timer is set to.
Ok. It's not what you said what's so ever...lol. Then please explain because it seems to me you think these kids should just be able to deal because mom and dad said I love you enough and told them not to believe the bullies. Kids do not think like that and saying that is a solution pretty much puts it right back on the kid.
Sorry--but it is largely on the kid. You can't change the world to accommodate you. You can't change the world to accommodate your kid.
If you want to march to the beat of your own drummer--great--but you better have the mental fortitude and resilience to deal with that, and if that is your kid, you'd better be teaching them that.
If you are teaching your kid that they can do whatever they want to--and everyone will react positively to it and things will all be great, then you are doing your child a great disservice.
Bullies are not going away--and there is only so much that can be done to reign in that type of behavior, especially with the omnipresent social media. The school can only control what happen during school--and even that is difficult.
No one can really control what happens online or on cell phones.
I'm glad you're not my dad. My dad would be on my side. Not making excuses for the damn bully. Some kids are bullied for things they have no control over. So what do they do then. Just take it like a man and the hell with dealing with the damn bullies. I never said anything about cyber bulling. The answer to that is don't go online. I'm not sure what you want some kid with a lisp to do about the freaking bully who makes his life hell while you tell him to man up and LGS tells him he's loved...lol. That sure seems to be working so well.
It makes ZERO difference whose "side" anyone is on. You can't change the world to fit your view just because you want it that way.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
No one can control what happens? Really? So we send our kids to school for eight hours a day and just throw our hands up about what's allowed to happen? Spoken like a person who allows this to happen because of course boys will be boys and girls will be girls and why do anything at all and you'll never stop all bullying. How about we stop the blatant stuff or is that too much to ask?
In answer to Husker. Not LGS.
-- Edited by Tinydancer on Saturday 6th of December 2014 10:50:25 PM
You can't control what happens. I've raised two kids--to think you can control everything that happens during the school day--PLUS everything that happens outside of it is purely delusional.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
I do agree that when bullying happens... the bully should be the one forced to leave school.
I agree. Bullies are usually good at covering their tracks though. This is where the social media aspect is a good thing- since there is proof. With a lot of bullying it would just be he said-she said.
What happens on social media outside of school time is not under the control of the school.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
Not teaching kids how to manage their own isn't helping them in anyway. Saying "poor baby" when Johnny called them a Poo Poo Head doesn't help your child. Yes, the teacher needs to take Johnny aside and correct him for name calling. And, if he persists, then a trip to the Principal, and up the administrative chain. But, how does correcting Johnny help your kid? If you don't ALSO teach your child how to be resilient, how to stand up for him/herself, and teach your child that yes, there are some real Aholes in the world and no you do not have to accept the words of idiots as your personal truth, then you are failing your child.
Sorry, not everyone has to LIKE your child.
And, Bullying is something that is difficult to define. Our neighbor's son had a lot of mental health issues. He is currently in jail now actually. But when he was in High School, he interpreted a lot of NOTHING as bullying. His PERCEPTIONS were skewed due to his personal issues where he imagined bullying if someone walked by and didn't say HI or whatever. Someone's perception is not necessarily the reality of the situation either.
Ok. It's not what you said what's so ever...lol. Then please explain because it seems to me you think these kids should just be able to deal because mom and dad said I love you enough and told them not to believe the bullies. Kids do not think like that and saying that is a solution pretty much puts it right back on the kid.
Sorry--but it is largely on the kid. You can't change the world to accommodate you. You can't change the world to accommodate your kid.
If you want to march to the beat of your own drummer--great--but you better have the mental fortitude and resilience to deal with that, and if that is your kid, you'd better be teaching them that.
If you are teaching your kid that they can do whatever they want to--and everyone will react positively to it and things will all be great, then you are doing your child a great disservice.
Bullies are not going away--and there is only so much that can be done to reign in that type of behavior, especially with the omnipresent social media. The school can only control what happen during school--and even that is difficult.
No one can really control what happens online or on cell phones.
I'm glad you're not my dad. My dad would be on my side. Not making excuses for the damn bully. Some kids are bullied for things they have no control over. So what do they do then. Just take it like a man and the hell with dealing with the damn bullies. I never said anything about cyber bulling. The answer to that is don't go online. I'm not sure what you want some kid with a lisp to do about the freaking bully who makes his life hell while you tell him to man up and LGS tells him he's loved...lol. That sure seems to be working so well.
It makes ZERO difference whose "side" anyone is on. You can't change the world to fit your view just because you want it that way.
So do nothing because Huskers says that's just the way the world is. Bull.
__________________
“Until I discovered cooking, I was never really interested in anything.” ― Julia Child ―
Agree 100% with the last two statements. At the end of the day, there is only so much the school authorities, or the authority authorities--can do, anyway. Not everything that will ever happen to your kid is a crime, violates a school rule, or will even be noticed. Simply wishing away the bullies hasn't worked and isn't going to. Despite the increased focus and attention on this issue over the last decade or two--these things continue to happen despite efforts at prevention.
Not everything can be prevented.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
No one can control what happens? Really? So we send our kids to school for eight hours a day and just throw our hands up about what's allowed to happen? Spoken like a person who allows this to happen because of course boys will be boys and girls will be girls and why do anything at all and you'll never stop all bullying. How about we stop the blatant stuff or is that too much to ask?
In answer to Husker. Not LGS.
-- Edited by Tinydancer on Saturday 6th of December 2014 10:50:25 PM
You can't control what happens. I've raised two kids--to think you can control everything that happens during the school day--PLUS everything that happens outside of it is purely delusional.
You keep bringing up social media. I've clearly stated if social media is the problem then just don't use it but when kids are being bullied and the only ones paying the consequence are them, not the bullies, that's just messed up. Clearly in your world there's nothing we can do about it but I don't think you say "oh well, that's just the way it is" and leave this kids to just buck up and take it.
__________________
“Until I discovered cooking, I was never really interested in anything.” ― Julia Child ―
""Clearly in your world there's nothing we can do about it but I don't think you say "oh well, that's just the way it is" and leave this kids to just buck up and take it.""
I am not sure why you keep saying this? Can you not handle a difference of opinion or approach so that if he doesn't agree with YOUR way then that means he wants to let bullies run wild or something?
Ahhh, excuse me. He said in his post that there's nothing to be done. How is me pointing that out mean I can't handle a difference of opinion? Seems to me you're having a problem with my difference of opinion...Geeesh
__________________
“Until I discovered cooking, I was never really interested in anything.” ― Julia Child ―
He said there's nothing that can be done. Go tell him that. And where did I ever say it's possible to stop all bullying. I said we need to do more about it but because you don't agree you're just doing what he does and twist words. Aren't you the one that always says it not all or nothing...lol
-- Edited by Tinydancer on Sunday 7th of December 2014 11:04:25 AM
__________________
“Until I discovered cooking, I was never really interested in anything.” ― Julia Child ―
Nobody has BLAMED this little child VOR. Go back and read.
Ok, actually, it was the parents who were blamed for letting the kid be in cheer. My fault. I'll edit.
I see the parent blamers are on their game!
Look, if my kid wants to play football and she's gonna get bullied for being a tomboy, I'm going to pull up on the parents of the little beasts. They don't get to tear my kid up because she's different. And my idea of parenting is to give my kid a **** ton of support regardless of what the bullies think.
__________________
I'm the Ginger Rogers of spelling...that means I'm smat.
Lesson learned in February: I don't have to keep up, I just have to keep moving!
Well, I didn't blame either one. But, I do support disciplining the bullies AND teaching your children how to stand up for themselves. But, yes, if your child is putting himself out there and in a way that different or draws attention, you also need to prepare your child for the backlash as well. I was a tom boy. I was the only girl to take Shop class and Woodshop class. So, yes, you have to be prepared that not everyone is going to agree with what you do. We are failing our kids if we are teaching them that the WORLD must agree with and approve of what they do. You need to teach your kids that who gives a damn if others "agree" with you or not?
We need to stop giving OTHER people permission to comment on our lives. Live life on your terms. Is it really anyone's business if you are living your life, following the law and paying your own bills? No. If I spend too much on a car or something, it is nobody's damn business. If I quit my job tomorrow to join a commune for 6 months, is that really your concern if you aren't funding my life? No. Yeah, we can all run our mouths about other people. And people yak, yak nonstop 24/7. But, why do we give them power over our lives? We need to stop worrying about the opinions of idiots.
I agree. It's my choice how to parent my kid and if I want to support her less than common choices, it's my responsibility to teach my kid how to handle pushback. When that pushback crosses the line from typical kid **** to bullying, I'm stepping in.
-- Edited by voiceofreason on Sunday 7th of December 2014 11:16:15 AM
__________________
I'm the Ginger Rogers of spelling...that means I'm smat.
Lesson learned in February: I don't have to keep up, I just have to keep moving!
What makes you think you can step in? Lots of kids don't tell their parents. There is bullying going on that you aren't even going to know about. So, no, you aren't going to be able to prevent it or stop it all the time.
No one can control what happens? Really? So we send our kids to school for eight hours a day and just throw our hands up about what's allowed to happen? Spoken like a person who allows this to happen because of course boys will be boys and girls will be girls and why do anything at all and you'll never stop all bullying. How about we stop the blatant stuff or is that too much to ask?
In answer to Husker. Not LGS.
-- Edited by Tinydancer on Saturday 6th of December 2014 10:50:25 PM
You can't control what happens. I've raised two kids--to think you can control everything that happens during the school day--PLUS everything that happens outside of it is purely delusional.
You keep bringing up social media. I've clearly stated if social media is the problem then just don't use it but when kids are being bullied and the only ones paying the consequence are them, not the bullies, that's just messed up. Clearly in your world there's nothing we can do about it but I don't think you say "oh well, that's just the way it is" and leave this kids to just buck up and take it.
What, pray tell, do you think we can do? Despite DECADES of school forums, teacher education, anti-bullying programs, "zero tolerance" rules for bullying--there continues to be bullies.
Sure, IF you can catch them in overt acts you can punish individuals--but that will do little to nothing to solve the overall problem.
You are long on b!tching but precious short on any real solutions.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
I agree. It's my choice how to parent my kid and if I want to support her less than common choices, it's my responsibility to teach my kid how to handle pushback. When that pushback crosses the line from typical kid **** to bullying, I'm stepping in.
-- Edited by voiceofreason on Sunday 7th of December 2014 11:16:15 AM
And do what? Beat up some kid? Challenge their parents to a physical brawl like some old Brady Bunch episode?
It might be a much better course of action to give your child the tools they need to be resilient, to be able to stand up to bullies, the tools to not become a victim.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
No one can control what happens? Really? So we send our kids to school for eight hours a day and just throw our hands up about what's allowed to happen? Spoken like a person who allows this to happen because of course boys will be boys and girls will be girls and why do anything at all and you'll never stop all bullying. How about we stop the blatant stuff or is that too much to ask?
In answer to Husker. Not LGS.
-- Edited by Tinydancer on Saturday 6th of December 2014 10:50:25 PM
You can't control what happens. I've raised two kids--to think you can control everything that happens during the school day--PLUS everything that happens outside of it is purely delusional.
You keep bringing up social media. I've clearly stated if social media is the problem then just don't use it but when kids are being bullied and the only ones paying the consequence are them, not the bullies, that's just messed up. Clearly in your world there's nothing we can do about it but I don't think you say "oh well, that's just the way it is" and leave this kids to just buck up and take it.
What, pray tell, do you think we can do? Despite DECADES of school forums, teacher education, anti-bullying programs, "zero tolerance" rules for bullying--there continues to be bullies.
Sure, IF you can catch them in overt acts you can punish individuals--but that will do little to nothing to solve the overall problem.
You are long on b!tching but precious short on any real solutions.
Coming from you that is highly hilarious. I said the punishment for the bullies is not harsh enough. Make sure the damn bullies know that if they even get caught doing it once there are big consequences, not the little slap on the wrist they get now. Can you not debate without swearing? I don't argue with juveniles so if you continue to swear for absolutely no reason you can argue with yourself.
__________________
“Until I discovered cooking, I was never really interested in anything.” ― Julia Child ―
No one can control what happens? Really? So we send our kids to school for eight hours a day and just throw our hands up about what's allowed to happen? Spoken like a person who allows this to happen because of course boys will be boys and girls will be girls and why do anything at all and you'll never stop all bullying. How about we stop the blatant stuff or is that too much to ask?
In answer to Husker. Not LGS.
-- Edited by Tinydancer on Saturday 6th of December 2014 10:50:25 PM
You can't control what happens. I've raised two kids--to think you can control everything that happens during the school day--PLUS everything that happens outside of it is purely delusional.
You keep bringing up social media. I've clearly stated if social media is the problem then just don't use it but when kids are being bullied and the only ones paying the consequence are them, not the bullies, that's just messed up. Clearly in your world there's nothing we can do about it but I don't think you say "oh well, that's just the way it is" and leave this kids to just buck up and take it.
What, pray tell, do you think we can do? Despite DECADES of school forums, teacher education, anti-bullying programs, "zero tolerance" rules for bullying--there continues to be bullies.
Sure, IF you can catch them in overt acts you can punish individuals--but that will do little to nothing to solve the overall problem.
You are long on b!tching but precious short on any real solutions.
Coming from you that is highly hilarious. I said the punishment for the bullies is not harsh enough. Make sure the damn bullies know that if they even get caught doing it once there are big consequences, not the little slap on the wrist they get now. Can you not debate without swearing? I don't argue with juveniles so if you continue to swear for absolutely no reason you can argue with yourself.
Punishing individual bullies--no matter how harshly--is not a solution.
There is only so much punishment you can mete out for words if the bullying is not physical, you probably are not going to catch them, they will take their campaign to social media and out of the reach of the school.
Can you debate without throwing insults? You don't seem to be able to.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.