Dear Carolyn: I am in a very happy relationship with a great guy. We have been together a few years now but there is one issue. My boyfriend has a very close girl friend whose presence is a thorn in my side. When we first started dating and were asking the standard closest friend/who knows you best questions, she was the answer. He has since casually mentioned that years ago she confessed her love to him (he did not reciprocate). He also says she tells him everything.
While I understand they have been close friends for a long time, I cannot help being irked at their friendship. She seems to reach out to him on a somewhat regular basis to meet up for drinks; other times they go to movies and do other activities. He seems to think this is no big deal and doesn’t understand why I am bothered by an innocent friendship.
Carolyn Hax started her advice column in 1997, after five years as a copy editor and news editor in Style and none as a therapist. The column includes cartoons by "relationship cartoonist" Nick Galifianakis -- Carolyn's ex-husband -- and appears in over 200 newspapers. View Archive
I can be okay with their friendship for months at a time (occasionally giving myself a pep talk to not let it bother me), but every once in a while I just totally lose my cool over it and all my worries and insecurities bubble to the surface. They do have a natural chemistry and more similar backgrounds/personalities than my boyfriend and I, who despite our differences are a good match.
It seems to me that she still may have feelings for him, and I don’t understand why this girl hasn’t taken a step back. I wouldn’t mind if they hung out in groups and caught up every now and then, but I selfishly want to be the most important girl in my boyfriend’s life and I feel threatened by this lingering close friendship. I wish I could have the self-confidence to not worry about it, but nothing I do seems to work.
My boyfriend and I have had a few serious conversations about this, but after a couple months I find myself back in the same place. Any advice?
L.
Yes: Make up your mind, and stop looking for the situation to make up your mind for you.
Look at the way you surrender control:
●“A very close girl friend whose presence is a thorn in my side.” You see this as something being done to you, when in fact you chose to keep seeing him when he told you about her upfront.
●“I cannot help being irked.” Yes, you can. You can embrace the friend and friendship, or you can break up with this boyfriend. It might help you do the former, by the way, if you hang out with them sometimes, like couples and their respective besties tend to do.
●“I don’t understand why this girl hasn’t taken a step back.” You’ve waited years for her to do this, to fix the problem for you. That’s a lot of life to put in another person’s hands. Plus, you’re waiting for her to do what you would do in this situation, instead of recognizing that what she’d do is the only metric she’s going to use.
●“I wish I could have the self-confidence to not worry about it.” Okay. I wish my favorite pants still fit. All that means is chronic discontentment until I either exercise more or buy bigger clothes. So what’s it going to be for you — hard work to change your outlook, or the hard decision to give up on a relationship that’s never going to fit?
I know you think you’ve done the hard work, but I suspect “nothing . . . seems to work” because, deep down, you’re certain that you’re right and that she’s the one who needs to leave.
That never works. What does work is taking control only of what’s yours. Namely: “I selfishly want to be the most important girl in my boyfriend’s life.” That’s yours. That’s what you want, and it’s right because you get to decide what’s important to you. (Yes, just as this friend can choose to stay close to a guy who rejected her romantically, and just as your boyfriend can choose to stay close to his female best friend despite your discomfort with her.)
And since that’s what you want, own it. Sure, do another round of thinking and trying to accept the status quo, and see what you can do about bringing the friend into your life, too, instead of just hearing they’ve gone to a movie. Best friendships belong in the fabric of a couple’s shared life, not skulking off to the side. But if you ultimately decide you can’t see her as anything but a threat, then that’s what you say. “I can’t stay in a relationship where I’m constantly looking over my shoulder.” In other words, you can’t make anyone let go but you.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
Guy probably doesn't care about her anymore. Men think differently than women do.
__________________
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou
Personally, I lived through this. And I learned something about myself. I cannot be with a guy who is best friends with a woman. She evidently can't either. Time for her to cut her losses and find someone who feels the same.
If you are in a relationship and allow the other person to take advantage, then that is on you.
I'd be more curious about the relationship. The LW could very well be "the other woman".
__________________
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.
My best friends are guys. DH knows that there is absolutely nothing between me and them. One of them is an ex, who DH also befriended. Another, we joke about DH getting the "(Friend's Name) Bundle" when he married me. DH also befriended him. I've befriended DH's female friends too.
The only time I had a problem with a BF having a female friend was with one of my exes. Ex prioritized that female friend over our relationship and that pissed me off. Once, he cancelled a date night because the female friend needed help with her computer.
My best friends are guys. DH knows that there is absolutely nothing between me and them. One of them is an ex, who DH also befriended. Another, we joke about DH getting the "(Friend's Name) Bundle" when he married me. DH also befriended him. I've befriended DH's female friends too.
The only time I had a problem with a BF having a female friend was with one of my exes. Ex prioritized that female friend over our relationship and that pissed me off. Once, he cancelled a date night because the female friend needed help with her computer.
This. DH and I both have friends of the opposite sex. We never go out with them alone so there's nothing to worry about. But I do know that he occasionally talks to his friends when I'm not around and vice versa. We trust each other. Not a big deal. And really, if you're that insecure then you need to worry about the guys your SO is around. I mean they could pull him into moral depravity too!
__________________
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou
This so much perpetuates the sexism in the world. I mean, we allow gay guys to be BFFs but straight guys are out for women. Men can tell their straight or gay male friends all about their spouses, but if it is a female, its wrong.
A guy wants to chat with his guy friend or meet up for drinks or a movie in a genre that they may have in common or go watch a sports game, but if a woman does that...watch out, she's after your man.
**** that. It is offensive that just because I have a vagina, I cannot control myself around my male friends.
__________________
“One day, you will be old enough to start reading fairytales again.”
C.S.Lewis
Plus, this isn't something "new". This isn't a new relationship that he introduced after he started dating his girlfriend. It's been there all along and she's been fully aware of it.
Either accept the conditions as they are, or move on. Expecting others to adjust their lives to make you happy is silly--especially the "friend" who owes her absolutely nothing.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
My best friend is a guy, and that basically describes our friendship. We would never work as a couple, but make fantastic friends. If a boyfriend can't handle it, he needs to move on.
I have several guy friends and DH has several female friends. I have gone to dinner, movies, etc with my guy friends just as DH has with his female friends. It's just not a big deal. I go with Scott to movies DH doesn't want to see and he goes out with Charlotte to restaurants I don't like. Nothing scandalous about it.
I frankly don't care what others think it "looks like". It isn't their business and I don't answer to them. DH and I trust each other, I trust our friends, and I know none of us are interested in the other in a sexual way. These friends are some of the most supportive people we know in regards to our marriage.
The OP needs to decide if this is something she can live with or not. And she needs to act accordingly.
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
I have several guy friends and DH has several female friends. I have gone to dinner, movies, etc with my guy friends just as DH has with his female friends. It's just not a big deal. I go with Scott to movies DH doesn't want to see and he goes out with Charlotte to restaurants I don't like. Nothing scandalous about it.
I frankly don't care what others think it "looks like". It isn't their business and I don't answer to them. DH and I trust each other, I trust our friends, and I know none of us are interested in the other in a sexual way. These friends are some of the most supportive people we know in regards to our marriage.
The OP needs to decide if this is something she can live with or not. And she needs to act accordingly.
Until that picture is snapped and put out all over the internet for everyone to see. Pictures can be deceiving. We chose not to risk that.
__________________
America guarantees equal opportunity, not equal outcome...
I have several guy friends and DH has several female friends. I have gone to dinner, movies, etc with my guy friends just as DH has with his female friends. It's just not a big deal. I go with Scott to movies DH doesn't want to see and he goes out with Charlotte to restaurants I don't like. Nothing scandalous about it.
I frankly don't care what others think it "looks like". It isn't their business and I don't answer to them. DH and I trust each other, I trust our friends, and I know none of us are interested in the other in a sexual way. These friends are some of the most supportive people we know in regards to our marriage.
The OP needs to decide if this is something she can live with or not. And she needs to act accordingly.
Until that picture is snapped and put out all over the internet for everyone to see. Pictures can be deceiving. We chose not to risk that.
Risk of what?
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
I have several guy friends and DH has several female friends. I have gone to dinner, movies, etc with my guy friends just as DH has with his female friends. It's just not a big deal. I go with Scott to movies DH doesn't want to see and he goes out with Charlotte to restaurants I don't like. Nothing scandalous about it.
I frankly don't care what others think it "looks like". It isn't their business and I don't answer to them. DH and I trust each other, I trust our friends, and I know none of us are interested in the other in a sexual way. These friends are some of the most supportive people we know in regards to our marriage.
The OP needs to decide if this is something she can live with or not. And she needs to act accordingly.
Until that picture is snapped and put out all over the internet for everyone to see. Pictures can be deceiving. We chose not to risk that.
Risk of what?
Gossip. Both of us are in the public eye (he MUCH more than me). It could ruin our reputation therefore ruining a lot of what we do...
__________________
America guarantees equal opportunity, not equal outcome...
So you base what you do on what others might think even if nothing is going on?
I could give a rip less what anyone else thinks.
When it could cost us out livelihood? Most definitely. I am running for office next fall. One picture could break my chances of winning. Most of the people don't know about my marriage.
__________________
America guarantees equal opportunity, not equal outcome...
So you base what you do on what others might think even if nothing is going on?
I could give a rip less what anyone else thinks.
When it could cost us out livelihood? Most definitely. I am running for office next fall. One picture could break my chances of winning. Most of the people don't know about my marriage.
I Understand what ohfour is saying. the male friends I can see where for some people being seen with someone else will be a bad thing. For a lot of people in certain positions a innocent dinner with a friend of a different sex can start all kinds of rumors and ruin a persons reputation. Of course I live in a small town and people do gossip and in the case of oh four, being in the public eye you need to be careful. My husband wouldn't eat with a female co-worker by himself in our town but when they are on a business trip (it was not just him or her but other people went too, they just had a separate meeting) they went to eat together.
So you base what you do on what others might think even if nothing is going on?
I could give a rip less what anyone else thinks.
Exactly. I cannot control what others think of me. DH is quite used to managing his public appearance and it has never been an issue. If people snapped a picture of me eating dinner with Scott sitting across the table from me, what exactly would that prove? That I eat dinner? For all they know it could be a business meeting. I don't even know anyone that would think a thing of it. I don't live my life based off of a fear of what others think of me. I cannot and I will not make everyone happy. I worry about making my family happy. Every one else is of no consequence to me.
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
So you base what you do on what others might think even if nothing is going on?
I could give a rip less what anyone else thinks.
Exactly. I cannot control what others think of me. DH is quite used to managing his public appearance and it has never been an issue. If people snapped a picture of me eating dinner with Scott sitting across the table from me, what exactly would that prove? That I eat dinner? For all they know it could be a business meeting. I don't even know anyone that would think a thing of it. I don't live my life based off of a fear of what others think of me. I cannot and I will not make everyone happy. I worry about making my family happy. Every one else is of no consequence to me.
Not when they could directly effect my reputation...
__________________
America guarantees equal opportunity, not equal outcome...
So you base what you do on what others might think even if nothing is going on?
I could give a rip less what anyone else thinks.
Exactly. I cannot control what others think of me. DH is quite used to managing his public appearance and it has never been an issue. If people snapped a picture of me eating dinner with Scott sitting across the table from me, what exactly would that prove? That I eat dinner? For all they know it could be a business meeting. I don't even know anyone that would think a thing of it. I don't live my life based off of a fear of what others think of me. I cannot and I will not make everyone happy. I worry about making my family happy. Every one else is of no consequence to me.
Not when they could directly effect my reputation...
Thank God I am an unambitious farm girl with zero fvcks to give about my reputation. . .
So you base what you do on what others might think even if nothing is going on?
I could give a rip less what anyone else thinks.
Exactly. I cannot control what others think of me. DH is quite used to managing his public appearance and it has never been an issue. If people snapped a picture of me eating dinner with Scott sitting across the table from me, what exactly would that prove? That I eat dinner? For all they know it could be a business meeting. I don't even know anyone that would think a thing of it. I don't live my life based off of a fear of what others think of me. I cannot and I will not make everyone happy. I worry about making my family happy. Every one else is of no consequence to me.
Not when they could directly effect my reputation...
Thank God I am an unambitious farm girl with zero fvcks to give about my reputation. . .
Reputation means EVERYTHING when running for office...
__________________
America guarantees equal opportunity, not equal outcome...
And maybe, just maybe, if people gave a fvck about their reputation, then we wouldn't have all the government leeches that we have now. It used to be shameful to be on welfare, but not anymore...
__________________
America guarantees equal opportunity, not equal outcome...
I see both sides of this. If you are an unassuming person without a high profile job then no one is going to care about you or who you are out to eat with. But there are many high profile jobs or jobs that reputation plays into that it DOES make a difference. Politicians, pastors, and those in Hollywood come to mind right off the bat but I'm sure there are many others. It's definitely important to protect your reputation if you are a minister. But, with everything there is a price to pay.
__________________
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou
I see both sides of this. If you are an unassuming person without a high profile job then no one is going to care about you or who you are out to eat with. But there are many high profile jobs or jobs that reputation plays into that it DOES make a difference. Politicians, pastors, and those in Hollywood come to mind right off the bat but I'm sure there are many others. It's definitely important to protect your reputation if you are a minister. But, with everything there is a price to pay.
So you base what you do on what others might think even if nothing is going on?
I could give a rip less what anyone else thinks.
Exactly. I cannot control what others think of me. DH is quite used to managing his public appearance and it has never been an issue. If people snapped a picture of me eating dinner with Scott sitting across the table from me, what exactly would that prove? That I eat dinner? For all they know it could be a business meeting. I don't even know anyone that would think a thing of it. I don't live my life based off of a fear of what others think of me. I cannot and I will not make everyone happy. I worry about making my family happy. Every one else is of no consequence to me.
Not when they could directly effect my reputation...
Thank God I am an unambitious farm girl with zero fvcks to give about my reputation. . .
Reputation means EVERYTHING when running for office...
LOL!!!
What? I can think of a ton of politicians who have lousy reputations and they still got elected.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
I see both sides of this. If you are an unassuming person without a high profile job then no one is going to care about you or who you are out to eat with. But there are many high profile jobs or jobs that reputation plays into that it DOES make a difference. Politicians, pastors, and those in Hollywood come to mind right off the bat but I'm sure there are many others. It's definitely important to protect your reputation if you are a minister. But, with everything there is a price to pay.
In DH's line of work, reputation is the most important factor is getting a new job. He spends his days with teenage girls for heavens sake. If people don't trust him, he doesn't have a job.
However, seeing someone eat dinner with a person of the opposite sex would NEVER lead me to believe that person was having an affair. That would be the last thing I thought of. And if it is what people think when they see two people out - it says a lot more about the person who thinks it's scandalous than it does about the person eating dinner. Why would your mind even go there? If I see two people of the opposite sex eating dinner I am much more likely to wonder what they are having than what their sexual situation is.
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
And maybe, just maybe, if people gave a fvck about their reputation, then we wouldn't have all the government leeches that we have now. It used to be shameful to be on welfare, but not anymore...
That has nothing to do with what we are talking about. They aren't on welfare because some pic got put on Facebook.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
I see both sides of this. If you are an unassuming person without a high profile job then no one is going to care about you or who you are out to eat with. But there are many high profile jobs or jobs that reputation plays into that it DOES make a difference. Politicians, pastors, and those in Hollywood come to mind right off the bat but I'm sure there are many others. It's definitely important to protect your reputation if you are a minister. But, with everything there is a price to pay.
In DH's line of work, reputation is the most important factor is getting a new job. He spends his days with teenage girls for heavens sake. If people don't trust him, he doesn't have a job.
However, seeing someone eat dinner with a person of the opposite sex would NEVER lead me to believe that person was having an affair. That would be the last thing I thought of. And if it is what people think when they see two people out - it says a lot more about the person who thinks it's scandalous than it does about the person eating dinner. Why would your mind even go there? If I see two people of the opposite sex eating dinner I am much more likely to wonder what they are having than what their sexual situation is.
Shrug. I don't really care who does what or who thinks what. All I'm saying is that's how gossip gets started.
__________________
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou
I see both sides of this. If you are an unassuming person without a high profile job then no one is going to care about you or who you are out to eat with. But there are many high profile jobs or jobs that reputation plays into that it DOES make a difference. Politicians, pastors, and those in Hollywood come to mind right off the bat but I'm sure there are many others. It's definitely important to protect your reputation if you are a minister. But, with everything there is a price to pay.
In DH's line of work, reputation is the most important factor is getting a new job. He spends his days with teenage girls for heavens sake. If people don't trust him, he doesn't have a job.
However, seeing someone eat dinner with a person of the opposite sex would NEVER lead me to believe that person was having an affair. That would be the last thing I thought of. And if it is what people think when they see two people out - it says a lot more about the person who thinks it's scandalous than it does about the person eating dinner. Why would your mind even go there? If I see two people of the opposite sex eating dinner I am much more likely to wonder what they are having than what their sexual situation is.
Plus another thing...I live in a VERY VERY Conservative county. It's RARE that I see someone I know out with a member of the opposite sex. It just isn't done here...
__________________
America guarantees equal opportunity, not equal outcome...
I see both sides of this. If you are an unassuming person without a high profile job then no one is going to care about you or who you are out to eat with. But there are many high profile jobs or jobs that reputation plays into that it DOES make a difference. Politicians, pastors, and those in Hollywood come to mind right off the bat but I'm sure there are many others. It's definitely important to protect your reputation if you are a minister. But, with everything there is a price to pay.
In DH's line of work, reputation is the most important factor is getting a new job. He spends his days with teenage girls for heavens sake. If people don't trust him, he doesn't have a job.
However, seeing someone eat dinner with a person of the opposite sex would NEVER lead me to believe that person was having an affair. That would be the last thing I thought of. And if it is what people think when they see two people out - it says a lot more about the person who thinks it's scandalous than it does about the person eating dinner. Why would your mind even go there? If I see two people of the opposite sex eating dinner I am much more likely to wonder what they are having than what their sexual situation is.
Plus another thing...I live in a VERY VERY Conservative county. It's RARE that I see someone I know out with a member of the opposite sex. It just isn't done here...
So, they are all gay there in very conservative country?
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
I see both sides of this. If you are an unassuming person without a high profile job then no one is going to care about you or who you are out to eat with. But there are many high profile jobs or jobs that reputation plays into that it DOES make a difference. Politicians, pastors, and those in Hollywood come to mind right off the bat but I'm sure there are many others. It's definitely important to protect your reputation if you are a minister. But, with everything there is a price to pay.
In DH's line of work, reputation is the most important factor is getting a new job. He spends his days with teenage girls for heavens sake. If people don't trust him, he doesn't have a job.
However, seeing someone eat dinner with a person of the opposite sex would NEVER lead me to believe that person was having an affair. That would be the last thing I thought of. And if it is what people think when they see two people out - it says a lot more about the person who thinks it's scandalous than it does about the person eating dinner. Why would your mind even go there? If I see two people of the opposite sex eating dinner I am much more likely to wonder what they are having than what their sexual situation is.
Plus another thing...I live in a VERY VERY Conservative county. It's RARE that I see someone I know out with a member of the opposite sex. It just isn't done here...
So, they are all gay there in very conservative country?
You know what I mean. With the opposite sex that's NOT their spouse...
__________________
America guarantees equal opportunity, not equal outcome...
I get what ohfour is saying. A long time ago I went to the movies with my brother and we ran into some "friends" of his. Despite the fact that we look very similar and TOLD them that we were brother and sister, they had called his girlfriend before we got home to tell her that he was "at the movies with some girl."
People are terrible.
well, trust her with my life so the gender of her friends is pretty much inconsequential to me--have never been jealous so just not a concern--like husker, don't particularly give a damn what people in general think about our relationship
__________________
" the only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing. "--edmund burke
I know of NO married people that would be seen out with someone of the opposite sex that's not a family member...
I see it all the time. People out for business reasons especially. It's a shame that some people only see sone thing nefarious when they see two people out. It would never occur to me that there would be shenanigans going on. And if there WERE shenanigans, that isn't my business either.
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
I know of NO married people that would be seen out with someone of the opposite sex that's not a family member...
I see it all the time. People out for business reasons especially. It's a shame that some people only see sone thing nefarious when they see two people out. It would never occur to me that there would be shenanigans going on. And if there WERE shenanigans, that isn't my business either.
Me, too. It would be sexist for me to take out male business associates for lunch, and not any female ones.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
This town is too small for indiscretions. You can't go anywhere or do anything without someone seeing you. I do have single and married male friends and I'd eat a meal or go to a movie with them. BUT, remember the friend in the OP told the BF that she has feelings for him. That changes everything.
It all depends on where you live. My husband does take out femaile clients but he will take his vice president too. He is also a Deacon at our Church and we live in a small town. Wouldn't be a big deal in a larger city.
This town is too small for indiscretions. You can't go anywhere or do anything without someone seeing you. I do have single and married male friends and I'd eat a meal or go to a movie with them. BUT, remember the friend in the OP told the BF that she has feelings for him. That changes everything.
It changes things for the LW--and probably she should end things. That's not a general statement, though.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.
When I got hired for my current job, the HR manager, who is female, took me out to lunch. It would have been beyond bizarre not to. I don't see how people can even function if they can't trust themselves even that far.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.