A dog explains why Phoenix's pet store law is such a big win for shelter animals.
In the name of representation, I thought it'd be best if we let an actual dog tackle this topic, transcribed (and loosely translated into human-speak) by me, Evan Porter. Enjoy!
I was born a stray, but now I live in a shelter, which means I'm moving up in the world!
Don't feel too bad for me, though. I have lots of things to be excited about. I got a funny celebrity name when I got to the shelter (Esmeralda Gosling!) and — ohmygod does someone have food?
But there is some even more awesome news this week that has me and my puppy friends spinning in nonstop circles.
Two years ago, Phoenix told pet stores they were only allowed to sell rescue animals like me.
I was just a puppy back then, not the handsome hound you see today. Pet stores in Phoenix that sell dogs from puppy mills just got a whack on the nose from one of those people who wear black robes and bang those funny wooden hammers that look like something a dog ought to be allowed to chew on.
At Upworthy, we tell stories for a better world.Like us on Facebook to get them first:
At the time, some people weren't happy about the new rule and tried to get it thrown out, but this week, that fancy robe-wearing judge-person upheld the decision, which is great news for dogs like me (he also upheld the decision not to let dogs chew on his hammer thingy, which is not great news because it looks sooo chewable).
The judge's decision is important because there are these really bad places called puppy mills, and laws like this one are working to shut them down.
It turns out that most puppies sold in pet stores come from puppy mills; at least, that's what my human friends at the ASPCA say. I might only be a dog, but even I understand basic economics: Without the demand for their product (puppies!), these puppy mills are more likely to go away for good.
Yay!
It's good news for me and my pals, but not everyone is excited.
We don't see a lot of "purebred" puppies here at my shelter, but apparently, they're a big deal to some humans. This new law says pet stores can't sell dogs from breeders, and that's made some people pretty grumpy.
The owners of the Puppies 'N Love pet store in Phoenix got really mad about this back in 2013, and they "sued" the city — whatever that means. The owners said since the law said they couldn't sell dogs from breeders anymore, they would probably go out of business.
The American Kennel Club isn't a fan of this law either because they think it's more important for humans to be able to pick a specific breed of dog than it is to make sure puppy mills are shut down.
"AKC supports freedom of choice for pet purchasers," they said, and, "Those seeking a puppy of a particular breed … may be out of luck."
Well boo-freaking-hoo! It's mutts like me who end up living on the streets while breeders and puppy mills supply purebred puppies straight to pet stores. Why would a pet store want a brand new pup when there are already so many who need good homes?
And besides, I challenge you to find a purebred cuter than me.
I'll wait — I'm really good at "stay"!
Anything that gets us animals off the streets and into loving homes gets four paws up from me.
Maricopa County, where Phoenix sits (good boy, Phoenix!), is second in the nation in pet overpopulation. To give you a taste, my buddies at the Arizona Humane Society say there are about 250,000 free-roaming cats there, and from my time on the streets, I can confirm that I've sniffed at least that many butts.
If saving more animals in need (even cats, yuck) and shutting down cruel puppy mills means professional breeders have to take a hit, that seems like a pretty OK deal to me.
I don't know what a city councillor is, but this one from Phoenix City named Thelda Williams said something I really liked: "[This law] means more protection for puppy lovers and the puppies themselves. We have so many dogs in Arizona that need homes; we don't need to import them."
I'll shake on that.
About:
Thanks to the Badass Brooklyn Animal Rescue for the picture of Esmeralda, who by the way, it still available for adoption as of this writing! Check her out: She's a lovely and incredibly well-informed pup.
Want more good stuff?
Subscribe to our YouTube channel to stay tuned to the most meaningful videos on the web.
Sensational and substantial. Entertaining and enlightening. That's what you can expect here: no empty calories. Just a steady stream of the most irresistibly shareable stuff you can click on without feeling bad about yourself afterwards. Read more.
Subscribe
By submitting above you agree to the Upworthy privacy policy.
We don't have pet stores that sell puppies & kittens here anymore. Haven't seen one in years. They still sell fish & guinea pigs. The SPCA does have a small section where you can adopt a shelter animal but they aren't selling them.
We have one pet store that has been around for the last 20 years. I don't know how they are in business though. They sell very mixed breed (think bichon, terrier, and chihuahua mixed) cats and dogs for hundreds of dollars. I have never seen anyone buying one and I don't know who would pay that kind of money unless they were looking for a pure breed.
We have one pet store that has been around for the last 20 years. I don't know how they are in business though. They sell very mixed breed (think bichon, terrier, and chihuahua mixed) cats and dogs for hundreds of dollars. I have never seen anyone buying one and I don't know who would pay that kind of money unless they were looking for a pure breed.
It's a "front" for laundering mob money. Or they're selling drugs.
__________________
The Principle of Least Interest: He who cares least about a relationship, controls it.
What a BS law. They are artificially altering demand. That's not a free market system. People should be able to buy whatever kind of dog they want.
They still can. Just not from pet shops. They'll actually have to go through the breeders now and anybody who saw the conditions like those puppy mills would never buy a dog from them.
__________________
“Until I discovered cooking, I was never really interested in anything.” ― Julia Child ―
What a BS law. They are artificially altering demand. That's not a free market system. People should be able to buy whatever kind of dog they want.
They still can. Just not from pet shops. They'll actually have to go through the breeders now and anybody who saw the conditions like those puppy mills would never buy a dog from them.
Exactly! It isn't aimed at breeders as real breeders never sell through pet stores.
What a BS law. They are artificially altering demand. That's not a free market system. People should be able to buy whatever kind of dog they want.
They still can. Just not from pet shops. They'll actually have to go through the breeders now and anybody who saw the conditions like those puppy mills would never buy a dog from them.
Exactly! It isn't aimed at breeders as real breeders never sell through pet stores.
Husker, dependent upon your definition of a "real breeder", that may or may not be true - perhaps in your area it is. Here we have backyard breeders (aka someone who has unaltered dogs of any breed and wants a little extra money) who breed without any thought except for the few hundred in cash they might make for puppies, "close to pure bred". It is a terrible practice and our shelters are full.
We NEED laws here to stop pet shops, newspapers and CraigsList from selling. And I hate over-legislation and I hate too much government meddling in my life and taking away my freedoms piece by piece, but not as much as I hate shelters full of animals who should never have been produced and are now paying a horrific price for human greed.
We have one pet store that has been around for the last 20 years. I don't know how they are in business though. They sell very mixed breed (think bichon, terrier, and chihuahua mixed) cats and dogs for hundreds of dollars. I have never seen anyone buying one and I don't know who would pay that kind of money unless they were looking for a pure breed.
It's a "front" for laundering mob money. Or they're selling drugs.
Am I the only one who thinks this?
__________________
The Principle of Least Interest: He who cares least about a relationship, controls it.
We have one pet store that has been around for the last 20 years. I don't know how they are in business though. They sell very mixed breed (think bichon, terrier, and chihuahua mixed) cats and dogs for hundreds of dollars. I have never seen anyone buying one and I don't know who would pay that kind of money unless they were looking for a pure breed.
It's a "front" for laundering mob money. Or they're selling drugs.
Am I the only one who thinks this?
Yes.
__________________
“Until I discovered cooking, I was never really interested in anything.” ― Julia Child ―
Husker, dependent upon your definition of a "real breeder", that may or may not be true - perhaps in your area it is. Here we have backyard breeders (aka someone who has unaltered dogs of any breed and wants a little extra money) who breed without any thought except for the few hundred in cash they might make for puppies, "close to pure bred". It is a terrible practice and our shelters are full.
We NEED laws here to stop pet shops, newspapers and CraigsList from selling. And I hate over-legislation and I hate too much government meddling in my life and taking away my freedoms piece by piece, but not as much as I hate shelters full of animals who should never have been produced and are now paying a horrific price for human greed.
This is so beautifully stated HM. We have two shelter dogs. They are the cutest most adorable and best dogs in the world.
And no ed, they're probably making money off pet products. A lot of people are starting to pay more attention to what they feed their pets now. Some food can only be purchased at the pet store.
Here's my shelter babies! They're BFF's.
__________________
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou
My grandfather used to breed Boston Terriers. His bitch brought in some good money. He always sold the pups without a problem. Not sure how or the specifics. We took Peggy in when he and my grandmother moved up to Pollock Pines and brought her up after he was settled and had her area below the deck set up. We don't believe in having animals in the house, neither did he. But he had a really nice set up for Peggy outside with a heated doghouse and an air conditioned back porch for her to come in during summer.
What a BS law. They are artificially altering demand. That's not a free market system. People should be able to buy whatever kind of dog they want.
They still can. Just not from pet shops. They'll actually have to go through the breeders now and anybody who saw the conditions like those puppy mills would never buy a dog from them.
Exactly! It isn't aimed at breeders as real breeders never sell through pet stores.
So what? Pet shops should be able to sell puppies wherever they can get them. If there is a problem with a particular breeder--then aim the laws at that breeder.
Just because Farmer A abused his pigs doesn't mean all grocery stores should stop selling pork chops.
__________________
I'm not arguing, I'm just explaining why I'm right.
Well, I could agree with you--but then we'd both be wrong.