Dear Prudie, I have a brother two years my senior, and we’re in our late 20s. We don’t really have a relationship. I have recently learned a lot about Asperger’s syndrome, and after hours of research, I’m positive my brother is on the spectrum. He doesn’t really listen to what other people say and interrupts conversations; he lives in a world of habits and changing his routine makes him sick; he can’t understand other people’s feelings while having extreme feelings of his own; he has difficulty making friends; he has odd, repetitive behaviors, the list goes on. He’s never been diagnosed, and my parents never investigated his awkward behavior, and he was bullied when he was young. He is a very smart person, now with a master’s degree in engineering, and I am happy to know that he has a good job, a few close friends, and an active social life. I never understood his behavior was a syndrome, and not just him being rude, mean, or unpleasant. Now thinking about my brother makes me feel terribly sad, and also very guilty. I want to get along better with him. The question is, Do I tell him I think he has Asperger’s? He’s very sensitive and can get terribly upset when conversations turn too personal. What’s the best thing to do to become a better sister to my undiagnosed Aspie brother!
—Bad Sister
Dear Sister, Your brother is an engineer, so even though he has a hard time dealing with people, maybe if he thinks of himself as an engineering issue, he can understand himself—and even others—better. I suggest you start by giving him a copy of the superb Michael Lewis book (soon to be a motion picture), The Big Short. True, this book is about the economic meltdown, not Asperger’s, but one of the heroes of the book, Michael Burry, who saw the collapse coming, said of himself, “Only someone who has Asperger’s would read a subprime-mortgage-bond prospectus.” He realized he must be on the spectrum when his young son was diagnosed with Asperger’s. I think this could be a way to open this conversation with your brother, and bring him a similar insight about himself. I have heard from other adults who got this diagnosis later in life (sometimes a self-diagnosis), and they say it suddenly made everything that came before make sense. If your brother indeed has Asperger’s, it’s certainly not too late for him to get help, not to obliterate his differences, but to understand better what makes him tick and others tock
Her brother is an engineer. Knowing quite a few they are usually very bright and a little off. And I say that in a fond way. Seeing the bf is a Dr. of engineering! :P
So, if he has a "diagnosis' , then that somehow matters WHY?
Because then it gives insight to his sister as to why he acted the way he did. She says it explains why he was the way he was when she thought it was "him being rude, mean, or unpleasant".
__________________
“Until I discovered cooking, I was never really interested in anything.” ― Julia Child ―
Maybe he is just a matter of fact kind of guy? My younger son is a very matter of fact kind of guy. So, what seems terse or short is just his personality. And he just got accepted to college, the School of Engineering, lol.
Maybe he is just a matter of fact kind of guy? My younger son is a very matter of fact kind of guy. So, what seems terse or short is just his personality. And he just got accepted to college, the School of Engineering, lol.
Whatever his personality - it has caused his sister not to like him. If thinking he has Asperger's will improve their relationship, then let her think what she wants.
__________________
LawyerLady
I can explain it to you, but I can't understand it for you.
Okay, my thoughts. I have a son with severe aspergers. And by severe I mean it has totally disrupted our lives at times. If he doesn't want to believe he has aspergers and she insists on it then they will only be further apart. If she keeps it to herself it MIGHT help unless she starts to treat him with pity. They're both adults. He's managing to hold down a job and sounds like he's doing a decent job at dealing with life. So what if he doesn't have a huge amount of friends. I really think nothing will be gained here by her telling him.
__________________
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou
Whatever his personality - it has caused his sister not to like him. If thinking he has Asperger's will improve their relationship, then let her think what she wants.
Maybe he's just a jerk? Or maybe he doesn't realize he is being a jerk. Either way, she should just go have a conversation with him and ask him for what she wants. What is it she really wants from him that she is not getting? Sometimes you have spell it out. LIke "I really want you to take the time to come over and have dinner with me on my birthday", etc. Engineers like concrete examples. So, that is the approach I would take. Nothing would be served to say "oh you have this or that illness". Maybe he does, but so what? What would that change exactly? Spell out and ask for exactly what you want. Then, he either WILL or he WON'T. If he won't then maybe you are just not going to have a close relationship. NOt all sibs do.
I think she should mind her own business and stay out of it. If it helps her to think it and have a better relationship with him that's great, but she shouldn't say anything about her assumptions to anyone.
When Jesse was diagnosed it was like a light bulb went off. He even said so.
But he knew something was off himself to begin with.
What she can do is learn how to relate. How to communicate.
But her brother might not accept any of it and it could actually be detrimental to him.
__________________
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.