Yes, they are mean girls who shouldn't say what they said. Yes they should be nicer and more sportsmanlike. But you can't change people and make them something they aren't. It's easier to teach your kid to deal with it than it is to get people like that to see that they are being azzholes. Both of my girls went through a period when other girls were "picking" on them. I taught both girls to "ignore the haters" and just be themselves unapologetically. Was I thrilled that my kids were being picked on? Of course not. But it was an opportunity to teach them a valuable lesson or two. First, remember how this feels and don't ever treat someone this way. Second, your self worth comes from inside and from the people who love you. Be true to yourself and you will at least be able to look yourself in the mirror and be proud of what you see. Last, no one has to like you. It isn't the law. And wherever you go, I guarantee someone WON'T like you and there will be someone you don't like in return. Learn to ignore them, get the work done, and go home without letting them get to you.
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
You can try. You can go talk to the head coach and/or call the mom and have a conversation. But in reality, most people don't want to deal with things. Just because you might think this is a problem doesn't mean the Head Coach will see it that way. He might see 'kids being kids' or whatever. Look, i am not justifying it in anyway. And, if i could have DD go up and slap some of those girls, they would deserve it ! But, the reality is that there are some she is going to be on the same team with through all of her high school years. These are the school athletes. She has extended the olive branch many times only to get shot down. And, i have tried inviting them over and so forth and they revert back to the same baloney. DD now realizes that these particular girls are just girls who she happens to play basketball with, or softball or whatever sport they are in. That is all they are. Girls with whom she plays on the team with. And, she can fudge the rah, rah team thing during the season. But, when the season is over, she can be done with them. I wish it wasn't that way. I wish they were all great friends. And, she has some very good friends on the team. It is unfortunate and her team is unlikely to be all that they COULD be if you had girls who were team players. DD is a team player. She will pass the ball to the open man. These two girls will not pass DD the ball, even if she is wide open. It is stupid, it sucks and it is annoying. But, we can go around feeling pissed off all the time or we just deal with what is. We have to deal with what is. Zebras don't change their stripes.
We also have unreasonable expectations of girls' teams vs boys' teams. On boys' teams, crap like this happens all of the time and no one bats an eye. But we expect everything on girls' teams to be sunshine and rainbows and unicorn farts and for the girls to be "sisters for life". That's unrealistic. The only thing they need to be able to do is play the game on the field. Off the field, the don't have to be BFF's, they don't have to be "sisters for life", they don't even HAVE to be friendly. We don't expect it from boys' teams - we just expect them to get the job done - and we shouldn't expect it from girls' teams.
The team my DD is on now is the best, most successful team she has ever been on. And the fact is, most of these girls are not friends. They learned to get along on the field and then off the field it's another story. This is why they are so good. They don't feel bound by some unspoken rule to be best friends. They understand that they don't have to be to get the job done.
__________________
Out of all the lies I have told, "just kidding" is my favorite !
LGS and MM, I appreciate your input. I have not yet sent the letter or decided what to do, and I will definitely consider your points of view. I want to think it over, and let the emotional response die down before I act.
I agree, and we have told her that many times- that not everyone is nice, or will like her, or want to be her friend. We have told her and tried to help her develop thicker skin, because she is a sensitive child. We are trying to give her tools on how to handle this on her own. Where I'm stuck is that their mother is a coach who sees this and does not step in. I feel like if they at least had a different coach in the dugout they would be reprimanded or met with some opposition when they were acting like this, as it is now their behavior has no boundaries and it looks like it's condoned, to them and the rest of team who witness it.
Also, she is 8. She likes playing softball, but a lot of the enjoyment right now is being a part of a team and the friends she has there. I don't want this to discourage her from playing. But so far, we are not 'there' yet.
I mentioned I was going to talk to DH earlier, here is an update on that- He worked as an umpire for this league for many years and he said this type of behavior is not tolerated, and in his opinion, if I send the letter, only send it to the head coach for now, before going up to anyone higher. He knows plenty of league officials, so if it wasn't handled he could get in touch with any of them for further involvement if needed.
LGS and MM have given you good advice. I think that, given your daughter's age, I would send the email, letting her know that her parents will speak up for her when necessary. Then, if nothing changes, fall back on the advice given.
Does "picking your battles" get any easier as your children get older? Imho, a bit!
I think these kids are young enough that the sportsmanship is more important, and hopefully the coach and league see this, too. They aren't in high school vying for scholarships - they are young children, and the whole POINT of sports teams at that age is to teach them sportsmanship and how to be a team.
__________________
LawyerLady
I can explain it to you, but I can't understand it for you.
We also have unreasonable expectations of girls' teams vs boys' teams. On boys' teams, crap like this happens all of the time and no one bats an eye. But we expect everything on girls' teams to be sunshine and rainbows and unicorn farts and for the girls to be "sisters for life". That's unrealistic. The only thing they need to be able to do is play the game on the field. Off the field, the don't have to be BFF's, they don't have to be "sisters for life", they don't even HAVE to be friendly. We don't expect it from boys' teams - we just expect them to get the job done - and we shouldn't expect it from girls' teams.
The team my DD is on now is the best, most successful team she has ever been on. And the fact is, most of these girls are not friends. They learned to get along on the field and then off the field it's another story. This is why they are so good. They don't feel bound by some unspoken rule to be best friends. They understand that they don't have to be to get the job done.
OMG! That was soooo spot on! I wish i could give you a million likes for that!
LGS and MM, I appreciate your input. I have not yet sent the letter or decided what to do, and I will definitely consider your points of view. I want to think it over, and let the emotional response die down before I act.
I agree, and we have told her that many times- that not everyone is nice, or will like her, or want to be her friend. We have told her and tried to help her develop thicker skin, because she is a sensitive child. We are trying to give her tools on how to handle this on her own. Where I'm stuck is that their mother is a coach who sees this and does not step in. I feel like if they at least had a different coach in the dugout they would be reprimanded or met with some opposition when they were acting like this, as it is now their behavior has no boundaries and it looks like it's condoned, to them and the rest of team who witness it.
Also, she is 8. She likes playing softball, but a lot of the enjoyment right now is being a part of a team and the friends she has there. I don't want this to discourage her from playing. But so far, we are not 'there' yet.
I mentioned I was going to talk to DH earlier, here is an update on that- He worked as an umpire for this league for many years and he said this type of behavior is not tolerated, and in his opinion, if I send the letter, only send it to the head coach for now, before going up to anyone higher. He knows plenty of league officials, so if it wasn't handled he could get in touch with any of them for further involvement if needed.
That is very level headed. And, i think talking to the head coach is what you should do first and go from there. You also have to separate stupid girl drama from actual bullying, etc. I understand how you feel. I have been so angry many times over the way my DD has been treated by some on her team. It is very painful. But, MM is right. When my boys played, this never seemed to be an issue. Or, if it was, maybe it just didnt' bother me as much as it did with my daughter.
You are never wrong to stand up for your child. And, you should. But, you may not get the resolution that you wish for. Girls are very adapt at learning to dismiss other girls in passive aggressive ways. A glance, a look, a backhanded compliment, etc and those types of girls learn very quickly that they can continue their behavior in subtle ways that prevents anyone from being able to point to a specific comment, etc. And, when you see their mom, remember the apple doesn't fall far from the tree. Kids that are jerks usually have parents who are jerks.
The sad thing is that my DD is on a team with a lot of athletic girls. Probably the best crop of girl athletes to come around this town in a while. But, it is unlikely they will acheive the success that should achieve. Yes they win a lot of games. They were 14-4 and last season and the season before that. But, they do not play as a Team. Girls, unlike boys, cannot seperate the drama. And, the one girl who is the bully is totally uncoachable. I know , because DH and I and another coach worked with their team all through elementary school into 6th grade. This girl has athletic ability, yet is uncoachable. SHe plays bully basketball with a lot of pushing and shoving and she is very aggressive. We have worked hard to teach her skills but she simply won't listen. Now that they are in JR High, she is very ineffective on the floor and has poor skills, poor shooting techinque and on and on. If they played like a team, they could go far. And, coaches have tried. But some of them simply will not. DD has kind of accepted that this is the reality for her school team. That is why she enjoys her travel team so much which has girls that simply love to play basketball, who play like a team and there is zero drama on this travel team so it can happen if you the right group of girls. But, that is a rare thing.
This is another reason why I hate organized sports.
Oh my gosh. There is a ton of GOOD about organized sports. My DD is becoming an amazing young, strong lady. She played with her travel team which is truly a team. They played one of the most grueling games and battled it out and i have never seen DD work so hard. She works hard but she was soaked with sweat. It was truly a fierce battle. She and her team perservered and won the game by 1 pt. It was great to see their hard work pay off. I really don't think that my DD would be such a strong young lady without sports. It has really molded her character and given her an inner strength. And, yes even dealing with all the bullcrap, that has also just made her stronger.
Ok, update. There was a game tonight. I'm just going to share everything that happened in order, so it might get confusing.
First, two sisters were harassing DD and their stepsister again. Telling them they couldn't be friends, etc. Step sister goes to her grandma and tells her. Grandma goes to the girls' mom/coach, mom/coach's response? "They're just kids" chuckle, shrug. Makes it much more obvious where her VSSs' get their attitude from.
Next, one of the sisters tried to trip DD. DD tells on her, the other sister steps in and says her sister didn't do it. Mom/coach believes her girls. Tells DD 'She did not, go sit back down' (or something similar, this was the story from an 8 year old).
After the game, this mom/coach gathers all the girls together to have a talk. I was chasing DD1 around and was not able to hear it, but was planning on asking DD8. Before I could talk to her about it though, my phone rings. It is another parent calling me because her daughter was telling her about the game and the talk (her daughter is completely innocent in all of this, has no idea that we've been having problems, basically was just sharing with her mom) and the mom was 'concerned' and 'really angry' about what she heard. And since it involved my DD, wanted to talk to me to verify. I told her everything that has been going on and about the tripping incident today. For one, she says her DD saw this other girl try to trip my DD and the mom/coach's reaction when DD told her. She says the sisters lied. Then, she tells me that the mom/coach was lecturing them on tattling, spreading rumors, etc. and called out DD specifically and in front of everyone and said 'Amanda(her daughter) didn't trip you, she didn't say anything about you, so let's stop with this! (again, this is her 8 year olds interpretation, but in her words she said it really mean).
She also confided that her daughter is not wanting to play on this team anymore because of how snotty these girls are.
So I called the head coach. He was very receptive, and assured me that he is going to think on it to figure out how to handle it, but that he wants every girl to want to come to practice, have fun, and feel safe. He will not allow anyone to be bullied- his words. We have another game Thursday and he said he would touch base with me again before then. I feel good about the conversation and I feel like he is taking it seriously. I am disappointed because the more I think about it, the more upset I am with the mom than I talked to him about, I feel like I put more emphasis on the girls' behavior. She had no right to tell my daughter what she did or did not experience, and she definitely should not have called her out in front of the whole team and basically call her a liar. So I might have to bring that up again we he gets in touch with me. I do not feel comfortable with her in any authoritative position over my kid.
Ok, update. There was a game tonight. I'm just going to share everything that happened in order, so it might get confusing.
First, two sisters were harassing DD and their stepsister again. Telling them they couldn't be friends, etc. Step sister goes to her grandma and tells her. Grandma goes to the girls' mom/coach, mom/coach's response? "They're just kids" chuckle, shrug. Makes it much more obvious where her VSSs' get their attitude from.
Next, one of the sisters tried to trip DD. DD tells on her, the other sister steps in and says her sister didn't do it. Mom/coach believes her girls. Tells DD 'She did not, go sit back down' (or something similar, this was the story from an 8 year old).
After the game, this mom/coach gathers all the girls together to have a talk. I was chasing DD1 around and was not able to hear it, but was planning on asking DD8. Before I could talk to her about it though, my phone rings. It is another parent calling me because her daughter was telling her about the game and the talk (her daughter is completely innocent in all of this, has no idea that we've been having problems, basically was just sharing with her mom) and the mom was 'concerned' and 'really angry' about what she heard. And since it involved my DD, wanted to talk to me to verify. I told her everything that has been going on and about the tripping incident today. For one, she says her DD saw this other girl try to trip my DD and the mom/coach's reaction when DD told her. She says the sisters lied. Then, she tells me that the mom/coach was lecturing them on tattling, spreading rumors, etc. and called out DD specifically and in front of everyone and said 'Amanda(her daughter) didn't trip you, she didn't say anything about you, so let's stop with this! (again, this is her 8 year olds interpretation, but in her words she said it really mean).
She also confided that her daughter is not wanting to play on this team anymore because of how snotty these girls are.
So I called the head coach. He was very receptive, and assured me that he is going to think on it to figure out how to handle it, but that he wants every girl to want to come to practice, have fun, and feel safe. He will not allow anyone to be bullied- his words. We have another game Thursday and he said he would touch base with me again before then. I feel good about the conversation and I feel like he is taking it seriously. I am disappointed because the more I think about it, the more upset I am with the mom than I talked to him about, I feel like I put more emphasis on the girls' behavior. She had no right to tell my daughter what she did or did not experience, and she definitely should not have called her out in front of the whole team and basically call her a liar. So I might have to bring that up again we he gets in touch with me. I do not feel comfortable with her in any authoritative position over my kid.
Wow, my momma bear would come out strong, and my next comments to the coach would likely be right in front of this woman as she got an earful about her treatment of my kid.
But - that's just me, and probably not the most diplomatic solution.
__________________
LawyerLady
I can explain it to you, but I can't understand it for you.
Mean girls suck. It is heartbreaking when a child goes through this. :( I feel sorry for you and your DD, its awful.
I agree, you really should talk to the coach but in all honesty, I don't know how much good it will do.
They really do. I don't get how their mom can witness it and just let it happen.
They got their behavior from somewhere.
If the mom responded with 'girls are mean' *shrug* I would have a hard time not responding with 'no, YOUR girls are mean. I'm going to file a complaint with the league about your allowing this behaviour to continue and you continuing favoritism towards your children at the expense of other players'.
Personally, if DD was in agreement, I would just pull her from the team.
She would definitely not be in agreement. She would be very upset if she had to stop playing.
I'm going to give the coach a chance to handle it. He seemed concerned.
Then she needs to know that if she continues, she will be picked on.
My boys (they will be 8 in a couple weeks) come home telling me of so and so cheating, or being mean or whatever and I ask why they continue to play with them if it's so bad.
NAOW - you do need to address coach/mom behavior otherwise this will not stop. She is the root of the problem. She called your daughter out in front of the team & called her a liar. It was bad enough that another team mom felt she needed to address it with you. Get that biotch kicked to the curb.
Personally, if DD was in agreement, I would just pull her from the team.
She would definitely not be in agreement. She would be very upset if she had to stop playing.
I'm going to give the coach a chance to handle it. He seemed concerned.
Then she needs to know that if she continues, she will be picked on.
My boys (they will be 8 in a couple weeks) come home telling me of so and so cheating, or being mean or whatever and I ask why they continue to play with them if it's so bad.
C'mon FNW! You need to teach the boys to rise above the losers, cheaters.
Personally, if DD was in agreement, I would just pull her from the team.
She would definitely not be in agreement. She would be very upset if she had to stop playing.
I'm going to give the coach a chance to handle it. He seemed concerned.
Then she needs to know that if she continues, she will be picked on.
My boys (they will be 8 in a couple weeks) come home telling me of so and so cheating, or being mean or whatever and I ask why they continue to play with them if it's so bad.
C'mon FNW! You need to teach the boys to rise above the losers, cheaters.
They also need to know that some people are jerks and either accept it and do your own thing, or walk away. I let them fight their own battles. No one is forcing them to play with these kids, and if they want to continue, then deal with it.
In this case, it is the coach/parent who is the problem which is different, IMO. A parent needs to address it-adult to adult.
Personally, if DD was in agreement, I would just pull her from the team.
She would definitely not be in agreement. She would be very upset if she had to stop playing.
I'm going to give the coach a chance to handle it. He seemed concerned.
Then she needs to know that if she continues, she will be picked on.
My boys (they will be 8 in a couple weeks) come home telling me of so and so cheating, or being mean or whatever and I ask why they continue to play with them if it's so bad.
OK. But she likes the rest of her team, she loves her coach, and she likes playing.
Yea, she's going to have to deal with them for now (which she's willing to do) while we get it figured out. And I think DH and I are leaning towards putting her on a different team next year if mom/coach is still going to be helping.
NAOW - you do need to address coach/mom behavior otherwise this will not stop. She is the root of the problem. She called your daughter out in front of the team & called her a liar. It was bad enough that another team mom felt she needed to address it with you. Get that biotch kicked to the curb.
I know. The more I think about the more upset I get. When Coach calls me back I am going to bring it up again. I might see if the other mom is willing to share with him what she shared with me too, strength in numbers...
NAOW - you do need to address coach/mom behavior otherwise this will not stop. She is the root of the problem. She called your daughter out in front of the team & called her a liar. It was bad enough that another team mom felt she needed to address it with you. Get that biotch kicked to the curb.
I know. The more I think about the more upset I get. When Coach calls me back I am going to bring it up again. I might see if the other mom is willing to share with him what she shared with me too, strength in numbers...
You may want to quietly speak with other mothers if you know any of them.
Personally, if DD was in agreement, I would just pull her from the team.
She would definitely not be in agreement. She would be very upset if she had to stop playing.
I'm going to give the coach a chance to handle it. He seemed concerned.
Then she needs to know that if she continues, she will be picked on.
My boys (they will be 8 in a couple weeks) come home telling me of so and so cheating, or being mean or whatever and I ask why they continue to play with them if it's so bad.
C'mon FNW! You need to teach the boys to rise above the losers, cheaters.
They also need to know that some people are jerks and either accept it and do your own thing, or walk away. I let them fight their own battles. No one is forcing them to play with these kids, and if they want to continue, then deal with it.
In this case, it is the coach/parent who is the problem which is different, IMO. A parent needs to address it-adult to adult.
Are you suggesting that I talk to mom/coach? I can, but Im having a hard time believing she'd be receptive to that.
Well, you could, but I'm not sure it would do any good.
Are you present during any of these occasions? Could you be? Or be watching stealthily?
I've been trying, but DH is out of town and it's hard to stay within earshot of the dugout with DD1. Once he is back the plan is for one of us to stay right there while the other one occupies DD1.