I clean my kids' rooms for them because it's my job, not theirs.
I'm preparing myself for a collective gasp from the internet as I make my revelation: I don't make my kids do chores. They don't even clean their own rooms.
Now hold on: This doesn't mean they don't lift a finger to help. I differentiate between chores and basic good manners (clearing plates from the table, tossing dirty clothes in the laundry basket, putting the mountain of LEGOs back into the box it was just tipped from).
You won't find my kids cleaning windows, hanging out laundry, emptying the dishwasher or sweeping the floor. I only give them one job to do, and that is to be a child. Their carefree days don't last forever. They will both have many, many years of doing mundane adult things like housework. I'd much rather see them have fun, enjoy their hobbies, nurture their passions and simply enjoy being children.
Because even as kids, they have plenty of responsibility to deal with. Pressure from school. Friendship dramas. Getting their heads around the fact that not everybody is kind and loving and that bad things happen to good people. While they're busy dealing with all of that, I'm more than happy to clean their rooms for them.
My decision is likely influenced by the fact that when I was a kid, I didn't have to clean my own room. My siblings and I helped out around the house, but we never had specific chores we had to do. And guess what? I don't live in a ****hole now. I like a clean, tidy house. Just because my parents didn't make me vacuum and sweep and scrub on a regular basis didn't mean I didn't know exactly how to do all those things as soon as I lived independently. It's not rocket science. I watched my mom keep our family home nice and that's what I've gone on to do as well.
Very occasionally, I do ask my kids (5 and 8) to clean their rooms. I always regret it. Kids that age don’t know how to tidy. Or maybe I’m too type-A to be able to deal with their, um, unique style of tidying. Whatever the reason, I always end up re-tidying. The outcome? Two tired, grouchy kids and a tired, grouchy mama, two rooms that have been tidied twice and an hour of our precious non-school time wasted.
I have no problem with moms who give their kids lists of chores to do. That's none of my business and I don't think they're being wrong or unfair. It's just different from how I bring up my kids, and surely we all know by now that there's no "right" way to be a parent.
Before you jump to conclusions, I can tell you, categorically, that my kids are not spoiled brats. I mean, I spoil them sometimes because they’re my kids and I’m not so old that I can’t remember that feeling of pure excitement when you get the LEGO set you’ve been pining for for weeks. The world is a crappy place a lot of the time, and I want to see smiles on their faces as often as possible.
But they’re not spoiled brats because they don’t expect to get everything they want, they appreciate what they do get, and they are sweet, polite, good-natured little people. They know how to behave in public and how to treat other people with acceptance, kindness and patience.
My children might not clean their rooms, but they spent a morning at a local warehouse helping me sort clothes and shoes and toiletries for refugee children who have nothing. They regularly gather up toys and books they no longer use and help me take them to the local charity shop. They know they are so, so lucky to have this life and not the lives of the children who live without food on their table, without love and security, or in constant fear of abuse or attack. I know they know this, because we talk about it. We talk about the big stuff, the stuff that will shape them into the adults I hope they will become.
If it’s a choice between spending time with them doing that, or nagging them to fold their laundry, I know what I’d rather do.
__________________
LawyerLady
I can explain it to you, but I can't understand it for you.
This is why we have a bunch of adults who don't know how to care for themselves. Heck, I see it in my ditzy neighbors. They are kind and educated, but can't do anything for themselves. They try, but fail so often.
Her kids, her choice. I don't see it as bad. She is teaching them the value of volunteering & that they are lucky to have what they have. I like her outlook.
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.
We were always made to help. Whatever our parents were doing around the house, we helped. When I was an adult living at home and paying room/board, I was required to vacuum and clean my bathroom. When I was a child, I was expected to make my bed and keep a tidy room/house. In other words, pick up after myself. And help with the household chores. But we did it as a team.
I had to make my bed, keep my room clean, set the table & dust on Saturday.
As an adult I don't make my bed, my room is rather messy, I never eat at the table & I loath dusting. I dust far less often than I vacuum or clean the bathrooms.
Granted my kids haven't had the field and animals to take care of, they do any and everything around the house, as well.
No one was or is made to do it, it's simply expected.
Many hands makes light work.
__________________
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.
Nice way to say all SAHM's are idiots. Not all of them act this way. I worked for many many many years but about five years ago when I quit my kids were still required to do chores. Still are to this day. Even SS is expected to pitch in when he comes over.
__________________
“You may shoot me with your words, you may cut me with your eyes, you may kill me with your hatefulness, but still, like air, I'll rise!” ― Maya Angelou
I don't know, I guess I do the same thing for Bunny. He has to pick up his toys and put his laundry in the basket.
Sometimes he helps vacuum or sets the table.
He's not very good at cleaning, I have to do it over if Bunny cleans anything.
I do think he will get better and we will let him help more when he is older.
I had to make my bed, keep my room clean, set the table & dust on Saturday.
As an adult I don't make my bed, my room is rather messy, I never eat at the table & I loath dusting. I dust far less often than I vacuum or clean the bathrooms.
This is me. I had to keep the house spotless. And now I'm a clutterbug. I still keep the dishes spotless, but I clean the bathrooms and stuff when they NEED it, or company is coming. My mother did not like my answer when she wondered allowed how she kept raising slobs. I told her it was backlash to being afraid of having a magazine out of place when she came home and having to clean everything every day as a kid.
Now, I think there is a happy medium. I think kids need to be responsible for their own spaces, their own stuff, and a couple of chores to help the household they live in.
__________________
LawyerLady
I can explain it to you, but I can't understand it for you.
DS is expected to help out around the apartment. He is learning to put stuff away when he's done with it. He knows to put dirty clothes into the hamper. He helps take out trash now. He's been helping with laundry and dishes for a year now.
I remember catching my mom remaking my bed one day.
It hurt my feelings.
I never said anything, but I always tried to do it better after that.
__________________
A flock of flirting flamingos is pure, passionate, pink pandemonium-a frenetic flamingle-mangle-a discordant discotheque of delirious dancing, flamboyant feathers, and flamingo lingo.
My feeling is that kids need to take ownership. Ownership in the home and family and the good of the home and family. As part of the family, you have a responsibility to pitch in and help keep the home clean and functional. Yes, you are responsible to clean your room. But not only your room. Every weekend, they get assigned a bathroom, vacuuming, scrubbing the kitchen or whatever. In my opinion, they need to learn that the work of caring for a home belongs to everyone who lives there.
It's like she needs validation. I had a neighbor that was such a helicopter mom she ended up in the psych ward when her youngest started school. She couldn't cope with not having a child to constantly fawn over and do everything for.
I never had chores. My mom did all the laundry. Sometimes she would have us take it to our rooms, and usually we had to put our own stuff away. I remember helping fold or carry, but it wasn't my responsibility. For as long as I can remember, we have had a cleaning lady come at least once a week - still do. I don't dust, vacuum, clean bathrooms, etc. I pick up after myself and do my laundry now.
I think I've turned into a pretty responsible adult. Instead of being assigned chores, we helped at the family business or tagged along to community service events. I watched how hard my parents worked and copied that. It just so happened that housework wasn't what they worked hard at.
I think the telling statement was that whenever she has her kids clean it's not good enough and she has to do it over. This was my mother and to this day I hate cleaning.
I was required to do quite alot of cleaning - but it was never good enough. I kept my room neat and my mother constantly came into my room to move tings around.
I think people need to stop being so controlling. If the kid does not do some thing perfect so what? The kid will learn and if you back off then they can take ownership. They should be internally motivated and they can't develope that in an Uber controlling environment.